Is this a good D3 Recruit for a team with a C- Prestige? He has 3 years of eligibility remaining.

Athleticism 42
Speed 52
Rebounding 4
Defense 45
Shot Blocking 1
Low-post 10
Perimeter 75
Ball Handling 35
Passing 52
Work Ethic 2
Stamina 73
Durability 41

A little slow. If his potential is good then yes he will be ok. edit his we is way to low scratch that he sucks

Brian would have had it right if he ever thought before posting: his WE is way too low, don't get him unless your team is bad enough that'd you'd be fine playing him at exactly those ratings for three years.

I disagree. That guy will be fine in D3. He won't be a star, but he'll be a good role player, especially for a C- prestige team.

The WE is very low, and he'll likely only improve a few points in each category over his career, but his ratings are fine for D3.

For comparison, this guy is currently leading all Allen D3 in 3PT%:

Athleticism 45
Speed 42
Rebounding 18
Defense 62
Shot Blocking 9
Low-post 1
Perimeter 51
Ball Handling 77
Passing 52
Work Ethic 43
Stamina 87
Durability 93
FT Shooting C-

and this guy is currently the leading scorer (among guards) in Allen D3:

Athleticism 40
Speed 59
Rebounding 21
Defense 52
Shot Blocking 16
Low-post 16
Perimeter 74
Ball Handling 42
Passing 34
Work Ethic 62
Stamina 93
Durability 71
FT Shooting C-

Times have certainly changed since a year ago, but those are good D3 players now.

Like I said, the guy you posted won't be the best player in D3 (and you may be able to find better recruits), but he should be decent.

HA - I'd worry about IQ with that WE, though.

Wow, looking at those guys on HA's team it's amazing how bad the players at D3 are. I remember my last season at Whitman in Tark I had a guy that was 79ath/80sp with a 68 per and he wasn't even the best guard in D3.

Im sorry but I would probally not play either of those guys very many minutes on my d3 team. The 2nd guy(astros 2nd) may be ok as a part time sf in d3. The first guy in the thread would be good possibly for a few minutes a game. just my .02

Here are a couple more.

Top 3pt% shooter in D3 Knight:

Athleticism 36
Speed 34
Rebounding 22
Defense 14
Shot Blocking 15
Low-post 14
Perimeter 58
Ball Handling 30
Passing 78
Work Ethic 44
Stamina 86
Durability 77
FT Shooting A+

Top scoring guard in D3 Knight:

Athleticism 56
Speed 66
Rebounding 19
Defense 30
Shot Blocking 25
Low-post 17
Perimeter 79
Ball Handling 63
Passing 28
Work Ethic 83
Stamina 100
Durability 37
FT Shooting B-

I guess I just dont get it.

To be clear, none of those guys I posted are on my teams, I just opened the Player Leader statistics for D3 and looked at the top player on the list.

I understand. All my guards are way better then this but do not lead any category and I won the title? In fact alot of them wouldnt even be on my team. Surprising

This post could not be converted. To view the original post's thread, click here.

agreed

Just for fun, here are some historical comparisons.

The best guard (performance-wise) on my current D3 team (B Prestige):

Name	Yr.	Pos.	A	SPD	REB	DE	BLK	LP	PE	BH	P	WE	ST	DU	FT	TOT
Craig Kenyon	Sr.	SG	78	49	16	54	17	19	54	66	31	65	90	47	A	586

Name	Yr.	Pos	GP	GS	MIN	FG%	FG3%	FT%	OREB	REB	AST	TO	STL	BLK	PF	PTS
C. Kenyon	Sr.	SG	24	24	23.5	.500	.413	.878	0.9	3.7	1.6	1.7	0.7	0.0	1.3	10.4

Here's what I considered a good D3 guard pre-potential (A+ Prestige):

Name	Yr.	Pos.	A	SPD	REB	DE	BLK	LP	PE	BH	P	WE	ST	DU	FT	TOT
David Hileman	Sr.	SG	53	75	24	31	15	12	81	87	87	53	86	49	B	653

Name	Yr.	Pos	GP	GS	MIN	FG%	FG3%	FT%	OREB	REB	AST	TO	STL	BLK	PF	PTS
D. Hileman	Sr.	SG	32	32	21.9	.488	.395	.720	0.3	2.0	3.2	1.3	0.6	0.1	2.1	11.4