If you had to pick one of the following players to be on your big league roster to play in the outfield who would you pick?

Option 1

http://whatifsports.com/HBD/Pages/Popups/PlayerProfile.aspx?pid=2169206

Option 2

http://whatifsports.com/HBD/Pages/Popups/PlayerProfile.aspx?pid=1630067

Option 3

http://whatifsports.com/HBD/Pages/Popups/PlayerProfile.aspx?pid=1656708

Right now I'm leaning towards option 2, I like his splits and I think option 1 could use another season or 2 in the minors and option 3 concerns me with the health rating......

Thanks in advance for any feedback.

Close between 2 and 3; depends somewhat on whether you have a y or righty dominated lineup.

I'd probably go with Option 3, personally. Who cares if he gets hurt? If he does, he goes to the DL and Option 2 gets his shot.

Probably 2, then 1, then 3. I don't think 3 should be in the conversation really. 2's splits make it so that he might actually hit the ball-- I've found that guys with bad contact and power ratings can still do well if they have obscene splits. Your guys splits aren't the best but they are good enough to make him not look like a fool at the plate. Plus he can steal bases better than the other 2.

I like 1 then 2, 1 already has 5 years pro service so he wont improve much more so bring him up now.

Can I choose option 4, none? And then try to find something better in the FA pool?

Quote: Originally posted by tropicana on 1/09/2010Can I choose option 4, none? And then try to find something better in the FA pool?

ditto- that' s a whole lotta suck for your buck.

Quote: Originally Posted By tropicana on 1/09/2010Can I choose option 4, none? And then try to find something better in the FA pool

There is nothing in the FA pool, hense having to take a player from my minor league system. Trust me, I was looking into the FA pool and players were going way to high for the payrol I had to bid with.

there's seriously not a single FA over that's not better than those guys? i find that hard to believe.

if true, trade for someone. there are always higher quality players available for cheap.

Quote: Originally Posted By deanod on 1/09/2010there's seriously not a single FA over that's not better than those guys? i find that hard to believe.

if true, trade for someone. there are always higher quality players available for cheap

This is where I wish that you could really peruse other worlds that you aren't in...I'll tell you right now I could go find 5 guys I would rather play than ANY of those guys.

Also, this question should be asked, since you didn't specify: WHICH position in the outfield? I'm suspicious that it might be center field.

Quote: Originally Posted By tropicana on 1/09/2010Also, this question should be asked, since you didn't specify: WHICH position in the outfield? I'm suspicious that it might be center field

Nope, LF/RF at CF I'm set.

As has been said, none of those guys are starter material. But 2 can play LF and steal a few bases. 3 will play better D.

They'd all be backups any any team I own.

What about this guy? Or this one?

They've been released (as have a few others) and are still looking for jobs in your World. Surely you can dig up someone better since you're able to look at the entirety of the available FA.

Quote: Originally Posted By pieo on 1/09/2010They'd all be backups any any team I own

i wouldn't waste a roster spot on those turds...i'd consider letting them start for my AAA team, though.