Ok, I know this has been tried in other worlds and figured I would give it a shot using my own formula. I took all the teams in Allen in D3 and calculated dynasty rankings using a formula for postseason success. Pts were awarded for NT and PI appearances and increased based on your performance. NT appearances weighted heaver than PI appearances. I took the last 5 years and the criteria to be included is simply 3 postseason appearances (NT or PI) in the last 5 years. Below are the results as well as calculations on top conferences (only listed ones with 3+ teams included in here). Let me know what you think.
1. Goucher
2. Milliken
3. Castleton St
4. St. Mary's
5. Illinois
6. Linfield
7. Lebanon
8. Whitworth
9. Marymount
10. Bethany
11. York
12. Rensselear Poly
13. St. Olaf
14. Anna Maria
15. Maine Maritime
16-25: Thomas, Webster, Elms, Maine/Presque Isle, Ohio Northern, Bowdoin, Augsburg, City COllege of NY, Chestnut Hill, Carthage
26-35: Mary Washington, Lewis and Clark, Ozarks, La Grange, Suffolk, Albertus Magnus, Nazareth, Philadelphia Biblical, Pitt Greensburgh, TX Lutheran
36-45: Williams, Millsaps, Occidental, Lasell, Westfield St, Connecticut, Piedmont, Hood, Guilford, Lynchburg
46-55: Lawrence, Depauw, Puget Sound, Bethel, Widener, Washington and Jefferson, Dennison, Macmurry, Rivier, Emmanuel
56-65: Luther, Gustavus Adolphus, St. Lawrence, Augustana, Case Western, McDaniel, Oglethorpe, Whitman, SUNY IT, Pacific
66-78: Ithaca, Clark, West Connecticut St, New Jersey City, Defiance, Hobart and William Smith, Chowan, Amherst, South Maine, Fisk, Framingham St, Alfred, Stevens Tech