When you say players not given scholarships are "returned to the recruiting pool," does that mean that the next year they can be nominated again or will act as if they had already been nominated?
Also, how would you feel about allowing, say, 3 days for coaches to apply to change schools after the end of the season. If multiple coaches apply for the same job, the winner could be determined by some formula like:
4*(wins previous season + 2*playoff wins + 10 for winning LCS + 10 for winning WS) +
2*(same stuff) 2 and 3 years beforehand +
1* (same stuff) season 4 years beforehand
I would also think a formula like that, while more complicated, could easily be calculated by excel and would be a more realistic method of calculating recruiting points.