#1
OV RA GL AS AA PC DU HE SP PA TP MK
Current - 6-1 176 69 76 63 77 64 1 75 85 70 59 95 82
Projected - 6-2 178 90 87 92 85 88 1 95 88 70 67 95 96

Batting and Pitching Ratings
Event Season CN PW LH RH BE BR BU PP
Current - 41 76 54 62 59 59 38 44
Projected - 46 87 71 74 72 82 51 45 25 8 10 15 0 30 88

#2
OV RA GL AS AA PC DU HE SP PA TP MK
Current - 6-0 183 75 78 63 78 67 5 73 98 86 76 78 97
Projected - 6-0 189 92 83 84 90 90 5 83 99 89 91 78 97

Batting and Pitching Ratings
Event Season CN PW LH RH BE BR BU PP
Current - 59 89 70 60 46 51 42 42
Projected - 73 93 93 69 56 65 52 43 31 9 16 16 8 38 75

Its super close but I think I like #2

#1's durablilty is whats keepin it close in my opinion

and im a sucker for a good batting eye

If they're the same age it's 2, and it's close but also obvious. But the projections make me guess that 1 is 18 and 2 is some college age, and if that's true then it's quite close. Both are legit #1 picks overall.

I'd go with 2 for sure. I don't like 1's splits enough to think that low of contact is good for a 1st overall pick.

theyre same age

if they're the same age go #2... he'll simple have a better chance at getting to projections...



but man i hate wasting that king of speed with a bad BR ratings..

I'd go with 2.

#1 in a heartbeat.

#2 in a heartbeat.

#2.

His current ratings are a little bit better, he's closer to projections, and has better health and makeup. A bit less risky than #1.

What hands do they bat with?

Quote: Originally posted by robusk on 5/24/2010What hands do they bat with?

unless they are named Pete Gray or Jim Abbott I'm gonna guess both...

#1 if he hits projections should win multiple gold gloves with average offence or better (for a SS), but #2 is a silver slugger with average SS defence. Normally I prefer gold glove defence, especially at SS, but even if #2 falls short on defensive projections, he is a good enough hitter to play 2B or 3B and maybe be a gold glover and silver slugger. I say #2 but it's closer than some are letting on (IMO).