Neighbor League Roster Thread Topic

Ott's About All

RFK Stadium
79,685,669

Beernoser

35 Giants (6)

Gus Mancuso (c)
Dick Bartell (SS)
Mel Ott (OF)
Hank Leiber (OF)
Roy Parmelee (P)
Leon Chagnon (P)

65 Senators (6)

Joe Cunningham (1B)
Ken Hamlin (2B)
Jim King (OF)
Mike McCormick (P)
Jim Duckworth (P)
Ron Kline (P)

55 KC A's (6)

Vic Power (1B)
Pete Suder (2B)
Elmer Valo (OF)
Hector Lopez (3B)
Enos Slaughter (OF)
Tom Gorman (P)

55 Indians (7)

Al Rosen (3B)
Hal Naragon (C)
Sam Dente (SS)
Mike Garcia (P)
Bob Lemon (P)
Early Wynn (P)
Sal Maglie (P)

Honestly that didn't go very well at all.

The 35 Giants turned out to be a bad first pick as the only guys I really got out of them were the two good outfielders. I should have gone with my other choice. At least the 55 Indians gave me a cheap starting rotation, but with a weak pitching staff and a weak 6-7-8 spots in the lineup, I'll be happy if I hit 500.


3/25/2023 1:23 AM (edited)
1935 Chicago Cubs 6
1955 Baltimore Orioles 6
1955 New York Yankees 6
1955 Cincinnati Reds 7


$79,819,140
STADIUM - TBD
TEAM NAME - TBD

2 Burgess, Smoky 1955 Cincinnati Reds
2 Moss, Les 1955 Baltimore Orioles
3 Kluszewski, Ted 1955 Cincinnati Reds
3 Robinson, Eddie 1955 New York Yankees
4 Temple, Johnny 1955 Cincinnati Reds
4 Young, Bobby 1955 Baltimore Orioles
5 Hack, Stan 1935 Chicago Cubs
5 Causey, Wayne 1955 Baltimore Orioles
8 Bauer, Hank 1955 New York Yankees
8 Post, Wally 1955 Cincinnati Reds
8 Klein, Chuck 1935 Chicago Cubs
8 Stainback, Tuck 1935 Chicago Cubs
8 Thurman, Bob 1955 Cincinnati Reds
6 McMillan, Roy 1955 Cincinnati Reds
6 Rizzuto, Phil 1955 New York Yankees


1 Podbielan, Bud 1955 Cincinnati Reds
1 Wilson, Jim 1955 Baltimore Orioles
1 Konstanty, Jim 1955 New York Yankees
1 Warneke, Lon 1935 Chicago Cubs
1 Root, Charlie 1935 Chicago Cubs
1 Wight, Bill 1955 Baltimore Orioles
1 Dorish, Harry 1955 Baltimore Orioles
1 Lee, Bill 1935 Chicago Cubs
1 Morgan, Tom 1955 New York Yankees
1 Sturdivant, Tom 1955 New York Yankees




3/25/2023 1:41 AM
TEAM NAME - DUTCH-IRISH MICKEY'S SKEETER RABBITS
STADIUM - POLO GROUNDS
SALARY - $79,887,097

'25 CINCINNATI REDS (7)
P - Pete Donohue
P - Eppa Rixey
C - Bubbles Hargrave
1B - Rube Bressler
1B - Al Niehaus
OF - Edd Roush
3B - Chuck Dressen

'25 NEW YORK GIANTS (6)
2B - George Kelly
3B - Frankie Frisch
SS - Travis Jackson
OF - Irish Meusel
OF - Hack Wilson
OF - Frank Walker

'35 PHILADELPHIA ATHLETICS (6)
OF - Wally Moses
2B - Rabbit Warstler
SS - Skeeter Newsome
P - Joe Cascarella
P - Dutch Lieber
P - Sugar Cain

'75 CALIFORNIA ANGELS (6)
C - Ellie Rodriguez
P - Jim Brewer
P - Frank Tanana
P - Ed Figueroa
P - Chuck Hockenbery
P - Mickey Scott
3/27/2023 2:31 AM (edited)
Deany’s Weenies
Sportsman Park
$79,932,345

1925 Cubs (6)

C Mike Gonzalez
3B Howard Freigau
OF Butch Weise
OF Jagger Statz
SS Rabbit Maranville
P Elmer Jacobs

1935 Cards (7)

1B Ripper Collins
2B Frankie Frisch
C Spud Davis
OF Ernie Orsatti
OF Terry Moore
P Paul Dean
P Dizzy Dean

1945 Red Sox (6)

2B Ben Steiner
SS Eddie Lake
1B Dolph Camilli
OF Bob Johnson
P Dave Ferriss
P Rex Cecil

1965 Dodgers (6)

3B Don Lejohn
P Don Drysdale
P Ron Perranoski
P Jim Brewer
P Nick Willhite
P Howie Reed

Good? Bad? Who knows?
( and he’s on 1st)

predicted record
Between

78-84 and 84-78
3/26/2023 12:15 PM (edited)
$79,773,890
Peckham Roses
Fenway

1935 Cincinnati Reds (6)
P Al Hollingsworth
OF Babe Herman
1B Billy Sullivan
OF Chick Hafey
P Don Brennan
P Paul Derringer

1945 Cincinnati Reds (6)
P Arnold Carter
P Boom-Boom Beck
P Frank Dasso
OF Hank Sauer
P Johnny Hetki
2B Woody Williams

1955 Boston Red Sox (6)
SS Eddie Joost
P Frank Sullivan
C Pete Daley
C Sammy White
3B Ted Lepcio
OF Ted Williams

1965 Cincinnati Reds (7)
3B Deron Johnson
1B Gordy Coleman
P Jim Duffalo
SS Leo Cardenas
2B Pete Rose
P Sammy Ellis
OF Vada Pinson
3/25/2023 2:31 PM
Oldtimer's roster is good. Sitemail sent with league number.
3/25/2023 2:35 PM
Team: Cream City Condors
Ballpark: County Stadium (Milwaukee, WI)
Total Salary: $79,923,103

After the success of last season's 101-win KC Sauce Jockeys, this crew has some big cleats to fill. I doubt we'll have another pitcher go 37-8 like '74 Phil Niekro did for the Jocks, but with these bats, I like our chances of winning more than we lose.

C SLB 1935 Rollie Hemsley
C MLW 1955 Del Rice
1B MLW 1955 Joe Adcock
1B HOU 1965 Jim Gentile
2B HOU 1965 Joe Morgan
2B MLW 1955 Jack Dittmer
3B MLW 1955 Eddie Mathews
3B PIT 1965 Gene Freese
SS SLB 1935 Lyn Lary
SS SLB 1935 Alan Strange
OF PIT 1965 Roberto Clemente
OF MLW 1955 Hank Aaron
OF SLB 1935 Moose Solters
OF HOU 1965 Al Spangler
OF PIT 1965 Jerry Lynch
P HOU 1965 Larry Dierker
P PIT 1965 Bob Veale
P PIT 1965 Don Cardwell
P HOU 1965 Robin Roberts
P HOU 1965 Claude Raymond
P HOU 1965 Turk Farrell
P MLW 1955 Ray Crone
P PIT 1965 Joe Gibbon
P SLB 1935 Bob Weiland
P SLB 1935 Snipe Hansen
3/25/2023 6:34 PM
Irish Twins
Memorial Stadrum
79,613,127

55 Pittsburgh Pirates (6)
2b Johnny O'Brien
SS Dick Groat
3b Dick Cole
C Jack Shepard
OF Eddie O'Brien
P Nellie King

65 Baltimore Orioles (7)
3b Brooks Robinson
P Milt Pappas
P Dave McNally
P Wally Bunker
P Steve Barber
P Stu Miller
P Dick Hall

75 Montreal Expos (6)
1b Mike Jorgensen
OF Larry Biittner
1b Jose Morales
2b Larry Lintz
OF Jim Dwyer
P Don Carrithers

65 Milwaukee Braves (6)
C Joe Torre
OF Hank Aaron
OF Felipe Alou
SS Mike De La Hoz
P Ken Johnson
P BIlly O'Dell

Pitching staff is very good, five solid starters and three studs in the pen. Offensively I am a bit worried. Left field is a platoon of good bat/no d Biittner and no bat/good d E. O'Brien. Second base is a four headed scrub monster as J. O'Brien, Lintz, Cole and De La Hoz will all see time there.
Great staff in a pitchers park. If we score enough we'll be ok.
3/25/2023 7:57 PM
Well I just posted my whole roster and wrote up my team, and when I hit submit it disappeared. Won't have time to redo it tonight. Fantastic!
3/25/2023 8:38 PM
Team name: Adele Dazeem
Forbes Field
Salary: $79,840,422

1925 Pittsburgh Pirates: 7
SS Glenn Wright
OF Kiki Cuyler
1B Stuffy McInnis
C Johnny Gooch
P Lee Meadows
P Ray Kremer
P Vic Aldridge

1975 Cleveland Indians: 6
1B Boog Powell
P Dennis Ekersley
P Gaylord Perry
P Dave LaRoche
P Tom Buskey
P Fred Beene

1945 Boston Braves: 6
OF Tommy Holmes
C Phil Masi
2B Frank Drews
OF Morrie Aderholt
P Mort Cooper
P Ira Hutchinson

1925 Brooklyn Robins: 6
2B Milt Stock
OF Zack Wheat
3B Jimmy Johnston
3B Andy High
SS Hod Ford
OF Dick Loftus

3/25/2023 8:43 PM
The Badlands
Riverfront
78;604;937

1975 Cinn 7
1B Tony Perez
OF George Foster
P Gary Nolan
P Don Gullett
P Rawley Eastwick
P Clay Carroll
P Fred Norman

1965 Det Tigers 6
C Bill Freehan
2B Jerry Lumpe
P Denny McLain
P Hank Aguirre
P Orlando Pena
P Terry Fox

1935 Braves 6
3B Pinky Whitney
OF Wally Berger
OF Hal Lee
C Shanty Hogan
OF Joe Mowry
1B Elbie Fletcher

1925Braves 6
P Joe Genewich
SS Dave Bancroft
2B Doc Gautreau
3B William Marriott
OFLes Mann
SS Bob Smith

i was really torn, I could have better pitching but then my starting lineup would basically be starting 2 scrubs in the infield. So here’s hoping.
3/27/2023 10:18 AM (edited)
summerfield is good
3/25/2023 10:17 PM
name TBD
Candlestick Park
$79,976,646

25 Tigers (6)
C Johnny Bassler
1B Lu Blue
2B Les Burke
SS Topper Rigney
OF Harry Heilmann
OF Bob Fothergill

65 Giants (7)
3B Jim Ray Hart
3B Jim Davenport
OF Willie Mays
P Juan Marichal
P Bobby Bolin
P Masanori Murakami
P Bill Henry

75 Tigers (6)
1B Jack Pierce
SS Tom Veryzer
OF Billy Baldwin
P Tom Walker
P Vern Ruhle
P Bob Reynolds

75 Padres (6)
C Randy Hundley
2B Tito Fuentes
OF Gene Locklear
P Randy Jones
P Brent Strom
P Sonny Seibert
3/26/2023 12:19 AM
razor's roster is good.

Drysdale and the Dean brothers.
3/26/2023 12:51 AM
ermocito's roster is good. Pete Rose bats in front of Ted Williams.
3/26/2023 1:50 AM
123 Next ▸
Neighbor League Roster Thread Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.