I've been working on comparing player stats - i.e., sim stats for real life stats. I have completed leagues 1 thru 5 so far (thru 92 games). I will post results below.

Note that all "real life" numbers are based on the raw real life stats, not the normalized stats. Also, I did not factor in home ballpark in any of the results. Obviously, an extreme home ballpark will skew the results.

Besides the player comparison, I also calculated a team comparison, which takes a real life stat (such as OPS or ERA) and applies it to the sim usage to get the "expected" stat.

LEAGUE 1 - HITTING
(Min 285 PA to qualify, sorted by biggest underachievers, measured by OPS difference)
.

			SIM	Actual
Name	Year__	Team Name	OPS___	OPS___	DIFF
Ruth, Babe	1930	NYY 1930-2017-1981-2022-2004	0.779	1.225	-0.446
Gehrig, Lou	1934	Yankees 1923,1934,1950,1978,2008	0.781	1.171	-0.390
Wheat, Zack	1924	Dodgers/Robins 18', 24, 52, 57, 66	0.640	0.977	-0.337
Gehrig, Lou	1927	Don't Yankee Ruth's Chain	0.917	1.239	-0.322
Bellinger, Cody	2019	Dodgers: 1916/1950/1994/2008/2019	0.720	1.035	-0.315
O Neill, Paul	1994	Yankees 1919-1937-1964-1994-2010	0.757	1.063	-0.306
Herman, Babe	1930	Dodgers 30/83/97/09/22	0.833	1.133	-0.300
Gehrig, Lou	1936	Bigwig's Yankees (36/43/57/58/69)	0.877	1.174	-0.297
Freeman, Freddie	2023	Dodgers 55-62-02-15-23	0.683	0.977	-0.294
Cano, Robinson	2007	Urband Yankees	0.548	0.841	-0.293
Howard, Elston	1963	L1: Yankees	0.578	0.870	-0.292
Piazza, Mike	1997	Dodgers 30/83/97/09/22	0.777	1.069	-0.292
Betts, Mookie	2023	Dodgers 55-62-02-15-23	0.699	0.987	-0.288
Beltre, Adrian	2004	5 Dodgers 1925 1963 1965 2004 2011	0.730	1.017	-0.287
Frederick, Johnny	1930	Dodgers 30/83/97/09/22	0.621	0.907	-0.286
Gehrig, Lou	1937	Yankees 1919-1937-1964-1994-2010	0.833	1.116	-0.283
Jeter, Derek	2004	NYY 1930-2017-1981-2022-2004	0.542	0.823	-0.281
Snider, Duke	1950	Dodgers: 1916/1950/1994/2008/2019	0.652	0.932	-0.280
Sheffield, Gary	2001	LAD 2021-2016-1954-2017-2001	0.720	1.000	-0.280
Guerrero, Pedro	1983	Dodgers 30/83/97/09/22	0.625	0.904	-0.279
Rolfe, Red	1936	Bigwig's Yankees (36/43/57/58/69)	0.610	0.885	-0.275
Judge, Aaron	2022	NYY 1930-2017-1981-2022-2004	0.837	1.111	-0.274
Gehrig, Lou	1930	NYY 1930-2017-1981-2022-2004	0.922	1.194	-0.272
Dimaggio, Joe	1939	Yankees: 1939/1946/1955/1997/2023	0.850	1.119	-0.269
Rodriguez, Alex	2007	Urband Yankees	0.799	1.067	-0.268
Lazzeri, Tony	1930	NYY 1930-2017-1981-2022-2004	0.567	0.834	-0.267
Ruth, Babe	1931	Yanks' Dickey x 2	0.928	1.194	-0.266
O Doul, Lefty	1932	32,48,53,75,88 Dodgers	0.715	0.978	-0.263
Ruth, Babe	1929	29,09,54,48,96 Yankees	0.866	1.127	-0.261
Dimaggio, Joe	1950	Yankees 1923,1934,1950,1978,2008	0.728	0.979	-0.251
Karros, Eric	1995	Puzzle Dodgers	0.658	0.904	-0.246
Mattingly, Don	1986	Urband Yankees	0.723	0.967	-0.244
Kemp, Matt	2011	5 Dodgers 1925 1963 1965 2004 2011	0.747	0.985	-0.238
Hudson, Orlando	2009	Dodgers 30/83/97/09/22	0.537	0.774	-0.237
Hodges, Gil	1954	LAD 2021-2016-1954-2017-2001	0.717	0.952	-0.235
Ruth, Babe	1923	Yankees 1923,1934,1950,1978,2008	1.075	1.309	-0.234
LeMahieu, DJ	2019	L1: Yankees	0.665	0.893	-0.228
Wright, Glenn	1930	Dodgers 30/83/97/09/22	0.679	0.903	-0.224
Boggs, Wade	1994	Yankees 1919-1937-1964-1994-2010	0.699	0.922	-0.223
Dimaggio, Joe	1940	Don't Yankee Ruth's Chain	0.830	1.051	-0.221
Dickey, Bill	1931	Yanks' Dickey x 2	0.605	0.820	-0.215
Gehrig, Lou	1932	Murderers Row	0.858	1.072	-0.214
Sheckard, Jimmy	1901	Dodgers take 2	0.730	0.941	-0.211
Snider, Duke	1956	L1: Dodgers	0.786	0.997	-0.211
Ruth, Babe	1932	Murderers Row	0.945	1.150	-0.205
High, Andy	1924	Dodgers/Robins 18', 24, 52, 57, 66	0.633	0.838	-0.205
Robinson, Jackie	1953	32,48,53,75,88 Dodgers	0.726	0.927	-0.201
Guerrero, Pedro	1985	Dodgers take 2	0.798	0.999	-0.201
Cano, Robinson	2009	29,09,54,48,96 Yankees	0.676	0.872	-0.196
Puig, Yasiel	2014	Puzzle Dodgers	0.670	0.862	-0.192
Cano, Robinson	2006	Yanks' Dickey x 2	0.699	0.890	-0.191
Snider, Duke	1953	32,48,53,75,88 Dodgers	0.857	1.046	-0.189
Mantle, Mickey	1958	Bigwig's Yankees (36/43/57/58/69)	0.846	1.035	-0.189
Robinson, Jackie	1948	32,48,53,75,88 Dodgers	0.632	0.820	-0.188
Ruth, Babe	1926	L1: Yankees	1.067	1.253	-0.186
Ward, Aaron	1923	Yankees 1923,1934,1950,1978,2008	0.589	0.773	-0.184
Dimaggio, Joe	1946	Yankees: 1939/1946/1955/1997/2023	0.694	0.878	-0.184
Snider, Duke	1955	Dodgers 55-62-02-15-23	0.863	1.046	-0.183
Fournier, Jack	1925	5 Dodgers 1925 1963 1965 2004 2011	0.832	1.015	-0.183
Mantle, Mickey	1959	Yankees 1904, 1928, 1942, 1959, 2014	0.722	0.904	-0.182
Jeter, Derek	2007	Urband Yankees	0.658	0.840	-0.182
Jeter, Derek	2006	Yanks' Dickey x 2	0.719	0.900	-0.181
Judge, Aaron	2017	NYY 1930-2017-1981-2022-2004	0.870	1.049	-0.179
Witt, Whitey	1923	Yankees 1923,1934,1950,1978,2008	0.618	0.794	-0.176
Hendrick, Harvey	1928	Dodgers 1941, 1949, 2003, 1928, 1982	0.699	0.875	-0.176
Snider, Duke	1957	Dodgers/Robins 18', 24, 52, 57, 66	0.780	0.955	-0.175
Furillo, Carl	1953	32,48,53,75,88 Dodgers	0.798	0.973	-0.175
Snider, Duke	1954	LAD 2021-2016-1954-2017-2001	0.897	1.070	-0.173
Snider, Duke	1952	Dodgers/Robins 18', 24, 52, 57, 66	0.689	0.862	-0.173
Williams, Bernie	1999	L1: Yankees	0.798	0.971	-0.173
Piazza, Mike	1995	Puzzle Dodgers	0.835	1.006	-0.171
Campanella, Roy	1953	32,48,53,75,88 Dodgers	0.838	1.006	-0.168
Mantle, Mickey	1957	Bigwig's Yankees (36/43/57/58/69)	1.010	1.177	-0.167
Davis, Willie	1972	Dodgers take 2	0.591	0.758	-0.167
Schang, Wally	1921	Murderers Row	0.714	0.881	-0.167
Cano, Robinson	2010	Yankees 1919-1937-1964-1994-2010	0.751	0.915	-0.164
Wheat, Zack	1925	5 Dodgers 1925 1963 1965 2004 2011	0.780	0.944	-0.164
Campanella, Roy	1955	Dodgers 55-62-02-15-23	0.818	0.978	-0.160
Berra, Yogi	1959	Yankees 1904, 1928, 1942, 1959, 2014	0.649	0.809	-0.160
Reese, Pee Wee	1949	Dodgers 1941, 1949, 2003, 1928, 1982	0.648	0.806	-0.158
Keller, Charlie	1941	Yanks' Dickey x 2	0.839	0.996	-0.157
Ruth, Babe	1921	Murderers Row	1.202	1.358	-0.156
Campanella, Roy	1952	Dodgers/Robins 18', 24, 52, 57, 66	0.649	0.805	-0.156
Ramirez, Manny	2008	Dodgers: 1916/1950/1994/2008/2019	0.877	1.031	-0.154
Robinson, Jackie	1951	Dodgers 1951,1964, 1969, 1980, 2018	0.802	0.956	-0.154
Jeter, Derek	2005	Don't Yankee Ruth's Chain	0.689	0.839	-0.150
Reiser, Pete	1941	Dodgers 1941, 1949, 2003, 1928, 1982	0.814	0.964	-0.150
McDougald, Gil	1956	Murderers Row	0.698	0.848	-0.150
Rizzuto, Phil	1942	Yankees 1904, 1928, 1942, 1959, 2014	0.568	0.717	-0.149
Dimaggio, Joe	1937	Yankees 1919-1937-1964-1994-2010	0.936	1.085	-0.149
Green, Shawn	2001	LAD 2021-2016-1954-2017-2001	0.822	0.970	-0.148
Hodges, Gil	1956	L1: Dodgers	0.715	0.861	-0.146
Turner, Trea	2021	LAD 2021-2016-1954-2017-2001	0.766	0.911	-0.145
Freeman, Freddie	2022	Dodgers 30/83/97/09/22	0.774	0.918	-0.144
Gehrig, Lou	1931	Yanks' Dickey x 2	0.965	1.108	-0.143
Gehrig, Lou	1929	29,09,54,48,96 Yankees	0.872	1.015	-0.143
Fournier, Jack	1924	Dodgers/Robins 18', 24, 52, 57, 66	0.824	0.964	-0.140
Ruth, Babe	1928	Yankees 1904, 1928, 1942, 1959, 2014	1.030	1.170	-0.140
Butler, Brett	1994	Dodgers: 1916/1950/1994/2008/2019	0.719	0.857	-0.138
Seager, Corey	2020	Puzzle Dodgers	0.805	0.943	-0.138
Machado, Manny	2018	Dodgers 1951,1964, 1969, 1980, 2018	0.768	0.905	-0.137
Gilliam, Jim	1956	L1: Dodgers	0.659	0.795	-0.136
Reese, Pee Wee	1948	32,48,53,75,88 Dodgers	0.619	0.753	-0.134
Dimaggio, Joe	1941	Yanks' Dickey x 2	0.950	1.083	-0.133
Mantle, Mickey	1955	Yankees: 1939/1946/1955/1997/2023	0.916	1.042	-0.126
Williams, Bernie	1998	Urband Yankees	0.871	0.997	-0.126
Piazza, Mike	1994	Dodgers: 1916/1950/1994/2008/2019	0.789	0.911	-0.122
Hodges, Gil	1951	Dodgers 1951,1964, 1969, 1980, 2018	0.783	0.901	-0.118
Reese, Pee Wee	1950	Dodgers: 1916/1950/1994/2008/2019	0.631	0.749	-0.118
Robinson, Jackie	1950	Dodgers: 1916/1950/1994/2008/2019	0.807	0.923	-0.116
Dimaggio, Joe	1936	Bigwig's Yankees (36/43/57/58/69)	0.812	0.928	-0.116
Galan, Augie	1943	Puzzle Dodgers	0.702	0.818	-0.116
Campanella, Roy	1950	Dodgers: 1916/1950/1994/2008/2019	0.799	0.915	-0.116
Jeter, Derek	2009	29,09,54,48,96 Yankees	0.759	0.871	-0.112
Herman, Billy	1943	Puzzle Dodgers	0.704	0.815	-0.111
Turner, Justin	2017	LAD 2021-2016-1954-2017-2001	0.834	0.945	-0.111
Davis, Tommy	1962	Dodgers 55-62-02-15-23	0.799	0.909	-0.110
Williams, Bernie	1997	Yankees: 1939/1946/1955/1997/2023	0.842	0.952	-0.110
Keller, Charlie	1942	Yankees 1904, 1928, 1942, 1959, 2014	0.821	0.930	-0.109
Ruth, Babe	1924	Don't Yankee Ruth's Chain	1.143	1.252	-0.109
Berra, Yogi	1954	29,09,54,48,96 Yankees	0.746	0.855	-0.109
Torres, Gleyber	2023	Yankees: 1939/1946/1955/1997/2023	0.694	0.800	-0.106
Gehrig, Lou	1926	L1: Yankees	0.864	0.969	-0.105
Sewell, Joe	1931	Yanks' Dickey x 2	0.674	0.778	-0.104
Gehrig, Lou	1928	Yankees 1904, 1928, 1942, 1959, 2014	1.012	1.115	-0.103
Walker, Dixie	1941	Dodgers 1941, 1949, 2003, 1928, 1982	0.741	0.843	-0.102
Robinson, Jackie	1952	Dodgers/Robins 18', 24, 52, 57, 66	0.808	0.905	-0.097
Robinson, Jackie	1949	Dodgers 1941, 1949, 2003, 1928, 1982	0.864	0.960	-0.096
Russell, Bill	1977	L1: Dodgers	0.569	0.664	-0.095
Rodriguez, Alex	2008	Yankees 1923,1934,1950,1978,2008	0.873	0.965	-0.092
Ruth, Babe	1927	Don't Yankee Ruth's Chain	1.168	1.259	-0.091
Keller, Charlie	1943	Bigwig's Yankees (36/43/57/58/69)	0.831	0.921	-0.090
McDougald, Gil	1957	Bigwig's Yankees (36/43/57/58/69)	0.718	0.804	-0.086
Mondesi, Raul	1997	Dodgers 30/83/97/09/22	0.815	0.901	-0.086
Chapman, Ben	1930	NYY 1930-2017-1981-2022-2004	0.764	0.844	-0.080
Jeter, Derek	1999	L1: Yankees	0.920	0.990	-0.070
LeMahieu, DJ	2020	Murderers Row	0.942	1.011	-0.069
Mantle, Mickey	1961	Urband Yankees	1.068	1.135	-0.067
Rodriguez, Alex	2005	Don't Yankee Ruth's Chain	0.965	1.031	-0.066
Murcer, Bobby	1971	Urband Yankees	0.906	0.970	-0.064
Mantle, Mickey	1956	Murderers Row	1.106	1.169	-0.063
Dimaggio, Joe	1948	29,09,54,48,96 Yankees	0.934	0.994	-0.060
Rizzuto, Phil	1950	Yankees 1923,1934,1950,1978,2008	0.799	0.857	-0.058
Hodges, Gil	1953	32,48,53,75,88 Dodgers	0.885	0.943	-0.058
Dickey, Bill	1939	Yankees: 1939/1946/1955/1997/2023	0.860	0.916	-0.056
Peckinpaugh, Roger	1919	Yankees 1919-1937-1964-1994-2010	0.740	0.794	-0.054
Reese, Pee Wee	1952	Dodgers/Robins 18', 24, 52, 57, 66	0.680	0.734	-0.054
Daly, Tom	1901	Dodgers take 2	0.763	0.815	-0.052
Lazzeri, Tony	1927	Don't Yankee Ruth's Chain	0.817	0.865	-0.048
Campanella, Roy	1951	Dodgers 1951,1964, 1969, 1980, 2018	0.936	0.983	-0.047
Wills, Maury	1962	Dodgers 55-62-02-15-23	0.676	0.720	-0.044
Gordon, Joe	1942	Yankees 1904, 1928, 1942, 1959, 2014	0.857	0.900	-0.043
Smith, Reggie	1977	L1: Dodgers	0.960	1.003	-0.043
Crawford, Willie	1973	Puzzle Dodgers	0.808	0.849	-0.041
Wills, Maury	1965	5 Dodgers 1925 1963 1965 2004 2011	0.624	0.659	-0.035
Guerrero, Pedro	1982	Dodgers 1941, 1949, 2003, 1928, 1982	0.880	0.914	-0.034
Berra, Yogi	1950	Yankees 1923,1934,1950,1978,2008	0.883	0.913	-0.030
Camilli, Dolph	1941	Dodgers 1941, 1949, 2003, 1928, 1982	0.936	0.963	-0.027
Keller, Charlie	1946	Yankees: 1939/1946/1955/1997/2023	0.928	0.938	-0.010
Ruth, Babe	1920	L1: Yankees	1.370	1.377	-0.007
Urshela, Gio	2020	Murderers Row	0.854	0.858	-0.004
Campanella, Roy	1949	Dodgers 1941, 1949, 2003, 1928, 1982	0.915	0.883	0.032
Cullenbine, Roy	1942	Yankees 1904, 1928, 1942, 1959, 2014	0.876	0.805	0.071

LEAGUE 1 - PITCHING
(Min 92 IP to qualify, sorted by biggest underachievers, measured by ERA difference)
.

Player	Year__	Team	Sim ERA	Act ERA	ERA Diff
Hershiser, Orel	1988	32,48,53,75,88 Dodgers	7.14	2.26	4.88
Chandler, Spud	1946	Yankees: 1939/1946/1955/1997/2023	6.93	2.10	4.83
Cole, Gerrit	2023	Yankees: 1939/1946/1955/1997/2023	6.80	2.63	4.17
Ford, Whitey	1955	Yankees: 1939/1946/1955/1997/2023	6.02	2.63	3.39
Bouton, Jim	1963	L1: Yankees	5.71	2.53	3.18
Kershaw, Clayton	2014	Puzzle Dodgers	4.91	1.77	3.14
Shawkey, Bob	1920	L1: Yankees	5.57	2.45	3.12
Grimes, Burleigh	1918	Dodgers/Robins 18', 24, 52, 57, 66	5.20	2.14	3.06
Quinn, Jack	1919	Yankees 1919-1937-1964-1994-2010	5.63	2.61	3.02
Urias, Julio	2022	Dodgers 30/83/97/09/22	5.18	2.16	3.02
Nomo, Hideo	1995	Puzzle Dodgers	5.55	2.54	3.01
Cole, Gerrit	2020	Murderers Row	5.80	2.84	2.96
Valenzuela, Fernando	1982	Dodgers 1941, 1949, 2003, 1928, 1982	5.80	2.87	2.93
Pettitte, Andy	1997	Yankees: 1939/1946/1955/1997/2023	5.81	2.88	2.93
Hoyt, Waite	1927	Don't Yankee Ruth's Chain	5.45	2.63	2.82
Terry, Ralph	1963	L1: Yankees	6.04	3.22	2.82
Ruffing, Red	1932	Murderers Row	5.87	3.09	2.78
Cone, David	1997	Yankees: 1939/1946/1955/1997/2023	5.54	2.82	2.72
Valenzuela, Fernando	1985	Dodgers take 2	5.06	2.45	2.61
Kershaw, Clayton	2011	5 Dodgers 1925 1963 1965 2004 2011	4.84	2.28	2.56
Ruffing, Red	1934	Yankees 1923,1934,1950,1978,2008	6.46	3.93	2.53
Brown, Kevin	2000	L1: Dodgers	5.09	2.58	2.51
Singer, Bill	1969	Dodgers 1951,1964, 1969, 1980, 2018	4.84	2.34	2.50
Hoyt, Waite	1923	Yankees 1923,1934,1950,1978,2008	5.50	3.02	2.48
Pfeffer, Jeff	1916	Dodgers: 1916/1950/1994/2008/2019	4.37	1.92	2.45
Peterson, Fritz	1971	Urband Yankees	5.48	3.05	2.43
Chandler, Spud	1943	Bigwig's Yankees (36/43/57/58/69)	4.07	1.64	2.43
Bahnsen, Stan	1968	Yanks' Dickey x 2	4.47	2.05	2.42
Vance, Dazzy	1930	Dodgers 30/83/97/09/22	4.94	2.61	2.33
Ford, Whitey	1961	Urband Yankees	5.51	3.21	2.30
Wyatt, Whit	1943	Puzzle Dodgers	4.76	2.49	2.27
Koufax, Sandy	1965	5 Dodgers 1925 1963 1965 2004 2011	4.30	2.04	2.26
Ford, Whitey	1956	Murderers Row	4.72	2.47	2.25
Maeda, Kenta	2016	LAD 2021-2016-1954-2017-2001	5.72	3.48	2.24
Greinke, Zack	2015	Dodgers 55-62-02-15-23	3.86	1.66	2.20
Messersmith, Andy	1975	32,48,53,75,88 Dodgers	4.49	2.29	2.20
Cheney, Larry	1916	Dodgers: 1916/1950/1994/2008/2019	4.06	1.92	2.14
Koufax, Sandy	1966	Dodgers/Robins 18', 24, 52, 57, 66	3.82	1.73	2.09
Pennock, Herb	1928	Yankees 1904, 1928, 1942, 1959, 2014	4.64	2.56	2.08
Buehler, Walker	2021	LAD 2021-2016-1954-2017-2001	4.54	2.47	2.07
Ford, Russ	1910	Yanks' Dickey x 2	3.69	1.65	2.04
Mays, Carl	1920	L1: Yankees	5.08	3.06	2.02
Sutton, Don	1975	32,48,53,75,88 Dodgers	4.87	2.87	2.00
Marquard, Rube	1916	Dodgers: 1916/1950/1994/2008/2019	3.57	1.58	1.99
Wyatt, Whit	1941	Dodgers 1941, 1949, 2003, 1928, 1982	4.32	2.34	1.98
Bonham, Tiny	1942	Yankees 1904, 1928, 1942, 1959, 2014	4.25	2.27	1.98
Shawkey, Bob	1919	Yankees 1919-1937-1964-1994-2010	4.69	2.72	1.97
Hooton, Burt	1975	32,48,53,75,88 Dodgers	4.78	2.82	1.96
Belcher, Tim	1988	32,48,53,75,88 Dodgers	4.87	2.91	1.96
Sutton, Don	1973	Puzzle Dodgers	4.37	2.42	1.95
Koufax, Sandy	1964	Dodgers 1951,1964, 1969, 1980, 2018	3.68	1.74	1.94
Ford, Whitey	1954	29,09,54,48,96 Yankees	4.76	2.82	1.94
Valenzuela, Fernando	1981	L1: Dodgers	4.40	2.48	1.92
Scherzer, Max	2021	LAD 2021-2016-1954-2017-2001	4.34	2.46	1.88
Ford, Whitey	1964	Yankees 1919-1937-1964-1994-2010	3.98	2.13	1.85
Reuss, Jerry	1982	Dodgers 1941, 1949, 2003, 1928, 1982	4.92	3.11	1.81
Stottlemyre Sr., Mel	1971	Urband Yankees	4.65	2.87	1.78
Moore, Wilcy	1927	Don't Yankee Ruth's Chain	4.06	2.28	1.78
Kershaw, Clayton	2013	Dodgers take 2	3.60	1.83	1.77
Sabathia, C.C.	2009	29,09,54,48,96 Yankees	5.14	3.37	1.77
Cortes, Nestor	2022	NYY 1930-2017-1981-2022-2004	4.18	2.44	1.74
Vance, Dazzy	1924	Dodgers/Robins 18', 24, 52, 57, 66	3.89	2.16	1.73
Gomez, Lefty	1931	Yanks' Dickey x 2	4.36	2.67	1.69
Vaughn, Hippo	1910	Yanks' Dickey x 2	3.52	1.83	1.69
Righetti, Dave	1981	NYY 1930-2017-1981-2022-2004	3.72	2.05	1.67
Buehler, Walker	2019	Dodgers: 1916/1950/1994/2008/2019	4.88	3.26	1.62
Pettitte, Andy	1996	29,09,54,48,96 Yankees	5.48	3.87	1.61
Hershiser, Orel	1985	Dodgers take 2	3.58	2.03	1.55
Sutton, Don	1980	Dodgers 1951,1964, 1969, 1980, 2018	3.75	2.20	1.55
Tanaka, Masahiro	2016	Don't Yankee Ruth's Chain	4.58	3.07	1.51
Kershaw, Clayton	2016	LAD 2021-2016-1954-2017-2001	3.14	1.63	1.51
Mays, Carl	1921	Murderers Row	4.55	3.05	1.50
Johnson, Randy	2005	Don't Yankee Ruth's Chain	5.25	3.79	1.46
Kershaw, Clayton	2015	Dodgers 55-62-02-15-23	3.58	2.13	1.45
Brown, Kevin	1999	Dodgers take 2	4.44	3.00	1.44
Guidry, Ron	1981	NYY 1930-2017-1981-2022-2004	4.18	2.76	1.42
Perez, Odalis	2002	Dodgers 55-62-02-15-23	4.40	3.00	1.40
Ford, Whitey	1958	Bigwig's Yankees (36/43/57/58/69)	3.41	2.01	1.40
Kershaw, Clayton	2012	L1: Dodgers	3.89	2.53	1.36
Kershaw, Clayton	2009	Dodgers 30/83/97/09/22	4.13	2.78	1.35
Newcombe, Don	1956	L1: Dodgers	4.35	3.06	1.29
Drysdale, Don	1964	Dodgers 1951,1964, 1969, 1980, 2018	3.46	2.18	1.28
Sutton, Don	1972	Dodgers take 2	3.34	2.08	1.26
Raschi, Vic	1948	29,09,54,48,96 Yankees	5.04	3.84	1.20
Reuss, Jerry	1980	Dodgers 1951,1964, 1969, 1980, 2018	3.55	2.51	1.04
Guidry, Ron	1978	Yankees 1923,1934,1950,1978,2008	2.73	1.74	0.99
Gomez, Lefty	1934	Yankees 1923,1934,1950,1978,2008	3.26	2.33	0.93
Wensloff, Butch	1943	Bigwig's Yankees (36/43/57/58/69)	3.42	2.54	0.88
Vance, Dazzy	1928	Dodgers 1941, 1949, 2003, 1928, 1982	2.93	2.09	0.84
Chesbro, Jack	1904	Yankees 1904, 1928, 1942, 1959, 2014	2.61	1.82	0.79
Gomez, Lefty	1937	Yankees 1919-1937-1964-1994-2010	3.09	2.33	0.76
Peterson, Fritz	1969	Bigwig's Yankees (36/43/57/58/69)	3.26	2.55	0.71
Koufax, Sandy	1962	Dodgers 55-62-02-15-23	3.25	2.54	0.71
Koufax, Sandy	1963	5 Dodgers 1925 1963 1965 2004 2011	2.46	1.88	0.58
May, Rudy	1981	NYY 1930-2017-1981-2022-2004	4.67	4.14	0.53
Vance, Dazzy	1925	5 Dodgers 1925 1963 1965 2004 2011	3.86	3.53	0.33

Here is the team total comparisons. Note that I added a column for "Exp HR" which shows the real life HR/AB rate times the number of sim ABs. This shows that teams that drafted HR hitters vs teams that didn't. It shouldn't be a surprse that teams that drafted more HR hitters tend to underachieve more.
.

Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Exp HR	Exp OPS	Act OPS	Diff
Dodgers 30/83/97/09/22	toysboys	Dodgers	129	0.927	0.699	-0.228
Dodgers: 1916/1950/1994/2008/2019	thejuice6	Dodgers	150	0.917	0.740	-0.177
32,48,53,75,88 Dodgers	kstober	Dodgers	127	0.923	0.746	-0.177
LAD 2021-2016-1954-2017-2001	footballmm11	Dodgers	179	0.952	0.775	-0.177
Dodgers/Robins 18', 24, 52, 57, 66	glowguy	Dodgers	102	0.866	0.690	-0.176
5 Dodgers 1925 1963 1965 2004 2011	BeAllEndAll	Dodgers	100	0.861	0.686	-0.175
Dodgers 55-62-02-15-23	redcped	Dodgers	146	0.918	0.747	-0.171
L1: Dodgers	3dayrotation	Dodgers	129	0.860	0.707	-0.153
Puzzle Dodgers	calhoop	Dodgers	101	0.861	0.715	-0.147
Dodgers 1951,1964, 1969, 1980, 2018	DarthDurron	Dodgers	146	0.896	0.763	-0.133
Dodgers take 2	Bill_James47	Dodgers	85	0.859	0.730	-0.129
Dodgers 1941, 1949, 2003, 1928, 1982	schwarze	Dodgers	109	0.901	0.811	-0.090
Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Exp HR	Exp OPS	Act OPS	Diff
NYY 1930-2017-1981-2022-2004	footballmm11	Yankees	190	1.001	0.754	-0.247
Yankees 1919-1937-1964-1994-2010	pedrocerrano	Yankees	150	0.977	0.779	-0.198
Bigwig's Yankees (36/43/57/58/69)	njbigwig	Yankees	154	0.979	0.802	-0.177
Urband Yankees	urband	Yankees	164	0.966	0.794	-0.172
Yanks' Dickey x 2	nocomm999	Yankees	136	0.967	0.795	-0.171
Yankees 1923,1934,1950,1978,2008	mllama54	Yankees	128	0.951	0.783	-0.169
L1: Yankees	3dayrotation	Yankees	160	1.011	0.843	-0.168
29,09,54,48,96 Yankees	jrig21	Yankees	133	0.927	0.766	-0.162
Yankees: 1939/1946/1955/1997/2023	thejuice6	Yankees	152	0.941	0.792	-0.149
Don't Yankee Ruth's Chain	Jtpsops	Yankees	195	1.050	0.902	-0.148
Murderers Row	Taxman2008	Yankees	178	1.023	0.881	-0.141
Yankees 1904, 1928, 1942, 1959, 2014	schwarze	Yankees	122	0.916	0.808	-0.108

Pitching Team Total Comparison
.

Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Act ERA	Exp ERA	ERA Diff
32,48,53,75,88 Dodgers	kstober	Dodgers	5.23	2.57	2.66
Dodgers/Robins 18', 24, 52, 57, 66	glowguy	Dodgers	4.43	2.08	2.35
Puzzle Dodgers	calhoop	Dodgers	4.53	2.28	2.25
L1: Dodgers	3dayrotation	Dodgers	4.81	2.59	2.21
Dodgers: 1916/1950/1994/2008/2019	thejuice6	Dodgers	4.49	2.28	2.21
Dodgers 1941, 1949, 2003, 1928, 1982	schwarze	Dodgers	4.52	2.45	2.07
Dodgers 30/83/97/09/22	toysboys	Dodgers	4.11	2.31	1.80
Dodgers take 2	Bill_James47	Dodgers	4.02	2.23	1.79
Dodgers 1951,1964, 1969, 1980, 2018	DarthDurron	Dodgers	4.01	2.29	1.73
Dodgers 55-62-02-15-23	redcped	Dodgers	3.99	2.37	1.61
LAD 2021-2016-1954-2017-2001	footballmm11	Dodgers	4.00	2.46	1.54
5 Dodgers 1925 1963 1965 2004 2011	BeAllEndAll	Dodgers	3.83	2.44	1.39
Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Act ERA	Exp ERA	ERA Diff
Yankees: 1939/1946/1955/1997/2023	thejuice6	Yankees	6.83	2.54	4.29
L1: Yankees	3dayrotation	Yankees	5.43	2.65	2.78
Urband Yankees	urband	Yankees	5.68	3.07	2.61
Murderers Row	Taxman2008	Yankees	5.47	2.91	2.56
Yanks' Dickey x 2	nocomm999	Yankees	4.52	2.17	2.35
29,09,54,48,96 Yankees	jrig21	Yankees	5.21	3.15	2.06
Yankees 1923,1934,1950,1978,2008	mllama54	Yankees	4.48	2.64	1.85
Yankees 1919-1937-1964-1994-2010	pedrocerrano	Yankees	4.18	2.34	1.84
Bigwig's Yankees (36/43/57/58/69)	njbigwig	Yankees	4.12	2.31	1.81
Don't Yankee Ruth's Chain	Jtpsops	Yankees	4.32	2.67	1.65
NYY 1930-2017-1981-2022-2004	footballmm11	Yankees	4.37	2.72	1.65
Yankees 1904, 1928, 1942, 1959, 2014	schwarze	Yankees	3.75	2.24	1.51

LEAGUE 2 - HITTING
(Min 285 PA to qualify, sorted by biggest underachievers, measured by OPS difference)
.

Name	Year__	Team Name	Sim OPS	Act OPS	DIFF
Bonds, Barry	2004	2004, 1934, 1913, 1907, 2007 Giants	0.945	1.421	-0.476
Giambi, Jason	2000	Oakland Athletics	0.707	1.123	-0.416
Bonds, Barry	2001	Giants 17/38/63/01/16	0.987	1.378	-0.391
Bonds, Barry	2000	Bonds/Bonds/Mays	0.766	1.128	-0.362
Bonds, Barry	2002	Bonds/Bonds/Mays	1.040	1.381	-0.341
Simmons, Al	1932	Athletics' Bender x 2	0.576	0.916	-0.340
Simmons, Al	1930	Puzzle Athletics	0.809	1.131	-0.322
Foxx, Jimmie	1932	Athletics' Bender x 2	0.897	1.218	-0.321
Terry, Bill	1930	Gigantes gigantes	0.757	1.071	-0.314
Lindstrom, Freddy	1930	Gigantes gigantes	0.693	1.000	-0.307
Bonds, Barry	2003	SFG 2003-1903-2015-1994-1962	0.971	1.278	-0.307
Holliday, Matt	2009	Oakland Athletics	0.609	0.909	-0.300
Mays, Willie	1964	Gigantes gigantes	0.695	0.990	-0.295
Chapman, Sam	1941	OAK 2020-2019-1904-1969-1941	0.628	0.921	-0.293
Kent, Jeff	2000	Bonds/Bonds/Mays	0.728	1.020	-0.292
McGwire, Mark	1996	90 MVP Rickey	0.906	1.197	-0.291
Bonds, Bobby	1970	L2: Giants	0.593	0.879	-0.286
Mays, Willie	1954	Bonds/Bonds/Mays	0.795	1.078	-0.283
Mays, Willie	1963	Giants 17/38/63/01/16	0.679	0.962	-0.283
Bonds, Barry	1994	SFG 2003-1903-2015-1994-1962	0.800	1.073	-0.273
Giambi, Jason	2001	Bigwig's Athletics (07/13/27/88/01)	0.865	1.137	-0.272
Jackson, Travis	1930	Gigantes gigantes	0.645	0.915	-0.270
Ott, Mel	1930	Gigantes gigantes	0.767	1.036	-0.269
Simmons, Al	1931	Athletics 1931 1972 1976 1906 1999	0.816	1.085	-0.269
Foxx, Jimmie	1934	L2: A's	0.834	1.102	-0.268
Foxx, Jimmie	1935	Oakland Athletics	0.829	1.097	-0.268
McCovey, Willie	1969	Giants 1904, 69, 96,2006, 21	0.850	1.109	-0.259
Foxx, Jimmie	1931	Athletics 1931 1972 1976 1906 1999	0.688	0.947	-0.259
Steinbach, Terry	1996	90 MVP Rickey	0.616	0.871	-0.255
Chapman, Matt	2018	Athletics: 1926/1928/1971/2005/2018	0.610	0.864	-0.254
McCovey, Willie	1970	L2: Giants	0.802	1.056	-0.254
Foxx, Jimmie	1930	Puzzle Athletics	0.817	1.066	-0.249
Bonds, Barry	1996	Giants 1904, 69, 96,2006, 21	0.829	1.076	-0.247
Foxx, Jimmie	1928	Athletics: 1926/1928/1971/2005/2018	0.717	0.964	-0.247
McCovey, Willie	1968	Bonds/Bonds/Mays	0.677	0.923	-0.246
Fain, Ferris	1951	Athletics 1902, 1912, 1981, 1944, 1951	0.677	0.922	-0.245
Ott, Mel	1938	Giants 17/38/63/01/16	0.783	1.025	-0.242
Tejada, Miguel	2003	90 MVP Rickey	0.576	0.808	-0.232
Ott, Mel	1929	5 Giants 1909 1929 1965 1992 2012	0.854	1.084	-0.230
Williams, Matt	1994	SFG 2003-1903-2015-1994-1962	0.696	0.926	-0.230
Jackson, Travis	1929	5 Giants 1909 1929 1965 1992 2012	0.630	0.857	-0.227
Ott, Mel	1934	2004, 1934, 1913, 1907, 2007 Giants	0.780	1.006	-0.226
Cochrane, Mickey	1932	Athletics' Bender x 2	0.698	0.922	-0.224
Bonds, Barry	1993	Gigantes gigantes	0.912	1.135	-0.223
Mays, Willie	1966	Spitters and Hitters	0.703	0.924	-0.221
Mays, Willie	1965	5 Giants 1909 1929 1965 1992 2012	0.825	1.043	-0.218
Tejada, Miguel	2001	Bigwig's Athletics (07/13/27/88/01)	0.585	0.802	-0.217
Tejada, Miguel	2002	Athletics 1911, 1929, 1974, 1994, 2002	0.645	0.862	-0.217
Velarde, Randy	1999	Athletics 1931 1972 1976 1906 1999	0.628	0.845	-0.217
Terry, Bill	1927	Giants Causeway	0.693	0.906	-0.213
Cepeda, Orlando	1963	Giants 17/38/63/01/16	0.718	0.929	-0.211
Durham, Ray	2004	2004, 1934, 1913, 1907, 2007 Giants	0.637	0.848	-0.211
Lindstrom, Freddy	1928	Spitters and Hitters	0.683	0.894	-0.211
Crawford, Brandon	2015	SFG 2003-1903-2015-1994-1962	0.573	0.783	-0.210
Bonds, Barry	1998	Spitters and Hitters	0.838	1.047	-0.209
Collins, Eddie	1910	Oakland Athletics	0.592	0.800	-0.208
Terry, Bill	1929	5 Giants 1909 1929 1965 1992 2012	0.733	0.940	-0.207
Jackson, Reggie	1969	OAK 2020-2019-1904-1969-1941	0.811	1.018	-0.207
Posey, Buster	2016	Giants 17/38/63/01/16	0.590	0.796	-0.206
Bando, Sal	1969	OAK 2020-2019-1904-1969-1941	0.679	0.884	-0.205
Semien, Marcus	2019	OAK 2020-2019-1904-1969-1941	0.689	0.891	-0.202
Simmons, Al	1929	Athletics 1911, 1929, 1974, 1994, 2002	0.841	1.040	-0.199
Mays, Willie	1962	SFG 2003-1903-2015-1994-1962	0.800	0.999	-0.199
Dark, Alvin	1953	Spitters and Hitters	0.625	0.823	-0.198
Johnson, Bob	1934	L2: A's	0.741	0.938	-0.197
Bishop, Max	1930	Puzzle Athletics	0.638	0.834	-0.196
Youngs, Ross	1924	L2: Giants	0.766	0.962	-0.196
Collins, Eddie	1911	Athletics 1911, 1929, 1974, 1994, 2002	0.737	0.932	-0.195
Henderson, Rickey	1990	90 MVP Rickey	0.822	1.016	-0.194
Bancroft, Dave	1921	Giants 1905, 1921, 1916, 1933, 1957	0.637	0.830	-0.193
Canseco, Jose	1990	90 MVP Rickey	0.722	0.914	-0.192
Foxx, Jimmie	1933	09,25,33,70,12 Athletics	0.963	1.152	-0.189
Foxx, Jimmie	1929	Athletics 1911, 1929, 1974, 1994, 2002	0.900	1.088	-0.188
Cabrera, Melky	2012	5 Giants 1909 1929 1965 1992 2012	0.719	0.906	-0.187
Cochrane, Mickey	1928	Athletics: 1926/1928/1971/2005/2018	0.674	0.859	-0.185
Simmons, Al	1928	Athletics: 1926/1928/1971/2005/2018	0.772	0.954	-0.182
Stanky, Eddie	1950	Giants: 1912/1931/1950/2011/2020	0.691	0.872	-0.181
Tenace, Gene	1976	Athletics 1931 1972 1976 1906 1999	0.652	0.831	-0.179
Terry, Bill	1934	2004, 1934, 1913, 1907, 2007 Giants	0.699	0.877	-0.178
Kent, Jeff	2001	Giants 17/38/63/01/16	0.700	0.876	-0.176
Tejada, Miguel	2000	Oakland Athletics	0.655	0.828	-0.173
Simmons, Al	1925	09,25,33,70,12 Athletics	0.846	1.018	-0.172
Brosius, Scott	1996	90 MVP Rickey	0.737	0.909	-0.172
Cochrane, Mickey	1929	Athletics 1911, 1929, 1974, 1994, 2002	0.716	0.887	-0.171
Mays, Willie	1957	Giants 1905, 1921, 1916, 1933, 1957	0.862	1.033	-0.171
Harper, George	1927	Giants Causeway	0.760	0.930	-0.170
Cochrane, Mickey	1931	Athletics 1931 1972 1976 1906 1999	0.806	0.976	-0.170
Mays, Willie	1958	Giants Causeway	0.833	1.002	-0.169
Lajoie, Nap	1901	L2: A's	0.939	1.106	-0.167
Baker, Frank	1911	Athletics 1911, 1929, 1974, 1994, 2002	0.722	0.887	-0.165
Cochrane, Mickey	1933	09,25,33,70,12 Athletics	0.809	0.974	-0.165
Lindstrom, Freddy	1929	5 Giants 1909 1929 1965 1992 2012	0.654	0.818	-0.164
Terry, Bill	1928	Spitters and Hitters	0.749	0.912	-0.163
Tejada, Miguel	1999	Athletics 1931 1972 1976 1906 1999	0.590	0.752	-0.162
Joost, Eddie	1951	Athletics 1902, 1912, 1981, 1944, 1951	0.709	0.870	-0.161
Dark, Alvin	1954	Bonds/Bonds/Mays	0.611	0.771	-0.160
Aurilia, Rich	2001	Giants 17/38/63/01/16	0.781	0.941	-0.160
Green, Dick	1969	OAK 2020-2019-1904-1969-1941	0.624	0.780	-0.156
Murphy, Danny	1911	Athletics 1911, 1929, 1974, 1994, 2002	0.705	0.859	-0.154
Kent, Jeff	1998	Spitters and Hitters	0.764	0.914	-0.150
Haas, Mule	1929	Athletics 1911, 1929, 1974, 1994, 2002	0.707	0.854	-0.147
Bell, David	2002	Bonds/Bonds/Mays	0.619	0.762	-0.143
Cramer, Doc	1935	Oakland Athletics	0.647	0.789	-0.142
Frisch, Frankie	1921	Giants 1905, 1921, 1916, 1933, 1957	0.729	0.869	-0.140
Ellis, Mark	2005	Athletics: 1926/1928/1971/2005/2018	0.721	0.861	-0.140
Murphy, Dwayne	1981	Athletics 1902, 1912, 1981, 1944, 1951	0.638	0.777	-0.139
Beltran, Carlos	2011	Giants: 1912/1931/1950/2011/2020	0.773	0.910	-0.137
Frisch, Frankie	1924	L2: Giants	0.720	0.855	-0.135
Canha, Mark	2019	OAK 2020-2019-1904-1969-1941	0.778	0.913	-0.135
Lajoie, Nap	1902	Athletics 1902, 1912, 1981, 1944, 1951	0.849	0.984	-0.135
Seybold, Socks	1901	L2: A's	0.767	0.900	-0.133
Sandoval, Pablo	2009	Giants Causeway	0.810	0.943	-0.133
Bresnahan, Roger	1903	SFG 2003-1903-2015-1994-1962	0.804	0.936	-0.132
Posey, Buster	2012	5 Giants 1909 1929 1965 1992 2012	0.826	0.957	-0.131
Durham, Ray	2006	Giants 1904, 69, 96,2006, 21	0.769	0.898	-0.129
Bando, Sal	1976	Athletics 1931 1972 1976 1906 1999	0.634	0.762	-0.128
Henderson, Dave	1988	Bigwig's Athletics (07/13/27/88/01)	0.764	0.888	-0.124
Collins, Eddie	1913	Bigwig's Athletics (07/13/27/88/01)	0.772	0.894	-0.122
Donaldson, Josh	2013	L2: A's	0.761	0.883	-0.122
Simmons, Al	1926	Athletics: 1926/1928/1971/2005/2018	0.835	0.956	-0.121
Collins, Eddie	1914	Athletics' Bender x 2	0.784	0.904	-0.120
Scutaro, Marco	2012	5 Giants 1909 1929 1965 1992 2012	0.635	0.753	-0.118
Higgins, Pinky	1935	Oakland Athletics	0.740	0.854	-0.114
Mays, Willie	1956	L2: Giants	0.813	0.926	-0.113
Joost, Eddie	1949	Puzzle Athletics	0.769	0.882	-0.113
Ott, Mel	1936	Giants Causeway	0.923	1.036	-0.113
Meyers, Chief	1913	2004, 1934, 1913, 1907, 2007 Giants	0.684	0.797	-0.113
Ott, Mel	1931	Giants: 1912/1931/1950/2011/2020	0.827	0.937	-0.110
Jackson, Reggie	1973	Athletics' Bender x 2	0.805	0.914	-0.109
Baker, Frank	1912	Athletics 1902, 1912, 1981, 1944, 1951	0.839	0.945	-0.106
Vizquel, Omar	2007	2004, 1934, 1913, 1907, 2007 Giants	0.515	0.621	-0.106
Baker, Frank	1914	Athletics' Bender x 2	0.721	0.822	-0.101
McCovey, Willie	1963	Giants 17/38/63/01/16	0.816	0.916	-0.100
Campaneris, Bert	1970	09,25,33,70,12 Athletics	0.673	0.769	-0.096
Bresnahan, Roger	1908	Giants Causeway	0.667	0.760	-0.093
Henderson, Rickey	1980	Puzzle Athletics	0.729	0.819	-0.090
North, Billy	1973	Athletics' Bender x 2	0.634	0.724	-0.090
Canseco, Jose	1988	Bigwig's Athletics (07/13/27/88/01)	0.871	0.960	-0.089
Jackson, Reggie	1971	Athletics: 1926/1928/1971/2005/2018	0.772	0.860	-0.088
Terry, Bill	1931	Giants: 1912/1931/1950/2011/2020	0.839	0.926	-0.087
Winn, Randy	2007	2004, 1934, 1913, 1907, 2007 Giants	0.724	0.798	-0.074
McGee, Willie	1990	90 MVP Rickey	0.720	0.792	-0.072
McGann, Dan	1905	Giants 1905, 1921, 1916, 1933, 1957	0.755	0.825	-0.070
Murphy, Danny	1905	90 MVP Rickey	0.660	0.728	-0.068
Johnson, Bob	1933	09,25,33,70,12 Athletics	0.826	0.892	-0.066
Jackson, Travis	1931	Giants: 1912/1931/1950/2011/2020	0.710	0.773	-0.063
Collins, Eddie	1909	09,25,33,70,12 Athletics	0.805	0.866	-0.061
Schoendienst, Red	1957	Giants 1905, 1921, 1916, 1933, 1957	0.737	0.795	-0.058
Baker, Frank	1913	Bigwig's Athletics (07/13/27/88/01)	0.859	0.906	-0.047
Campaneris, Bert	1973	Athletics' Bender x 2	0.586	0.626	-0.040
Snodgrass, Fred	1910	Spitters and Hitters	0.836	0.872	-0.036
Henderson, Rickey	1981	Athletics 1902, 1912, 1981, 1944, 1951	0.818	0.845	-0.027
Donlin, Mike	1905	Giants 1905, 1921, 1916, 1933, 1957	0.894	0.908	-0.014
Ott, Mel	1933	Giants 1905, 1921, 1916, 1933, 1957	0.827	0.834	-0.007
Posey, Buster	2021	Giants 1904, 69, 96,2006, 21	0.882	0.889	-0.007
Bresnahan, Roger	1904	Giants 1904, 69, 96,2006, 21	0.785	0.791	-0.006
Hornsby, Rogers	1927	Giants Causeway	1.032	1.034	-0.002

LEAGUE 2 - PITCHING
(Min 92 IP to qualify, sorted by biggest underachievers, measured by ERA difference)
.

Player	SN	Team	Sim ERA	Act ERA	ERA Diff
Langford, Rick	1980	Puzzle Athletics	7.39	3.26	4.13
Morgan, Cy	1909	09,25,33,70,12 Athletics	5.72	1.81	3.91
Grove, Lefty	1931	Athletics 1931 1972 1976 1906 1999	5.90	2.06	3.84
Plank, Eddie	1912	Athletics 1902, 1912, 1981, 1944, 1951	5.88	2.22	3.66
Dygert, Jimmy	1907	Bigwig's Athletics (07/13/27/88/01)	5.95	2.34	3.61
Morgan, Cy	1910	Oakland Athletics	4.98	1.55	3.43
Zito, Barry	2002	Athletics 1911, 1929, 1974, 1994, 2002	6.14	2.75	3.39
Plank, Eddie	1905	90 MVP Rickey	5.56	2.26	3.30
Schumacher, Hal	1933	Giants 1905, 1921, 1916, 1933, 1957	5.43	2.16	3.27
Moore, Mike	1989	Puzzle Athletics	5.82	2.61	3.21
Perry, Gaylord	1964	Gigantes gigantes	5.92	2.75	3.17
Mathewson, Christy	1910	Spitters and Hitters	4.76	1.89	2.87
Waddell, Rube	1906	Athletics 1931 1972 1976 1906 1999	5.08	2.21	2.87
Hubbell, Carl	1934	2004, 1934, 1913, 1907, 2007 Giants	5.17	2.30	2.87
Wiltse, Hooks	1909	5 Giants 1909 1929 1965 1992 2012	4.86	2.00	2.86
Schmidt, Jason	2002	Bonds/Bonds/Mays	6.18	3.45	2.73
Hunter, Catfish	1974	Athletics 1911, 1929, 1974, 1994, 2002	5.20	2.49	2.71
Grove, Lefty	1927	Bigwig's Athletics (07/13/27/88/01)	5.86	3.19	2.67
Hunter, Catfish	1972	Athletics 1931 1972 1976 1906 1999	4.68	2.04	2.64
Marichal, Juan	1964	Gigantes gigantes	5.09	2.48	2.61
Bender, Chief	1914	Athletics' Bender x 2	4.75	2.26	2.49
Mathewson, Christy	1913	2004, 1934, 1913, 1907, 2007 Giants	4.55	2.06	2.49
Grove, Lefty	1928	Athletics: 1926/1928/1971/2005/2018	5.03	2.58	2.45
Lincecum, Tim	2009	Giants Causeway	4.93	2.48	2.45
Waddell, Rube	1905	90 MVP Rickey	3.86	1.48	2.38
Perry, Gaylord	1968	Bonds/Bonds/Mays	4.81	2.44	2.37
Mathewson, Christy	1904	Giants 1904, 69, 96,2006, 21	4.38	2.03	2.35
Douglas, Phil	1919	L2: Giants	4.28	2.03	2.25
Blue, Vida	1975	L2: A's	5.22	3.01	2.21
Drucke, Louis	1910	Spitters and Hitters	4.68	2.47	2.21
Coombs, Jack	1906	Athletics 1931 1972 1976 1906 1999	4.61	2.50	2.11
Bender, Chief	1910	Oakland Athletics	3.65	1.58	2.07
Mathewson, Christy	1907	2004, 1934, 1913, 1907, 2007 Giants	4.06	2.00	2.06
Krause, Harry	1909	09,25,33,70,12 Athletics	3.44	1.39	2.05
Norris, Mike	1980	Puzzle Athletics	4.56	2.53	2.03
Blue, Vida	1976	Athletics 1931 1972 1976 1906 1999	4.37	2.35	2.02
Marichal, Juan	1969	Giants 1904, 69, 96,2006, 21	4.11	2.10	2.01
Mathewson, Christy	1908	Giants Causeway	3.44	1.43	2.01
Marichal, Juan	1966	Spitters and Hitters	4.21	2.23	1.98
Crandall, Doc	1910	Spitters and Hitters	4.53	2.56	1.97
Tesreau, Jeff	1912	Giants: 1912/1931/1950/2011/2020	3.91	1.96	1.95
Swift, Bill	1993	Gigantes gigantes	4.73	2.82	1.91
Plank, Eddie	1904	OAK 2020-2019-1904-1969-1941	4.07	2.17	1.90
Gray, Sonny	2015	L2: A's	4.60	2.73	1.87
Bender, Chief	1909	09,25,33,70,12 Athletics	3.52	1.66	1.86
Hunter, Catfish	1971	Athletics: 1926/1928/1971/2005/2018	4.80	2.96	1.84
Bender, Chief	1911	Athletics 1911, 1929, 1974, 1994, 2002	4.00	2.16	1.84
Blue, Vida	1971	Athletics: 1926/1928/1971/2005/2018	3.60	1.82	1.78
Coombs, Jack	1910	Oakland Athletics	3.07	1.30	1.77
Schupp, Ferdie	1917	Giants 17/38/63/01/16	3.71	1.95	1.76
Blue, Vida	1974	Athletics 1911, 1929, 1974, 1994, 2002	5.00	3.25	1.75
Schmidt, Jason	2004	2004, 1934, 1913, 1907, 2007 Giants	4.95	3.20	1.75
Bender, Chief	1913	Bigwig's Athletics (07/13/27/88/01)	3.95	2.21	1.74
Wiltse, Hooks	1908	Giants Causeway	3.96	2.24	1.72
Waddell, Rube	1904	OAK 2020-2019-1904-1969-1941	3.33	1.62	1.71
Bender, Chief	1907	Bigwig's Athletics (07/13/27/88/01)	3.74	2.05	1.69
Waddell, Rube	1902	Athletics 1902, 1912, 1981, 1944, 1951	3.68	2.05	1.63
Anderson, Fred	1917	Giants 17/38/63/01/16	3.06	1.44	1.62
Marichal, Juan	1963	Giants 17/38/63/01/16	3.95	2.41	1.54
Hubbell, Carl	1931	Giants: 1912/1931/1950/2011/2020	4.17	2.65	1.52
Antonelli, Johnny	1954	Bonds/Bonds/Mays	3.81	2.30	1.51
McGinnity, Joe	1903	SFG 2003-1903-2015-1994-1962	3.87	2.43	1.44
McGinnity, Joe	1904	Giants 1904, 69, 96,2006, 21	3.05	1.61	1.44
Mathewson, Christy	1909	5 Giants 1909 1929 1965 1992 2012	2.56	1.14	1.42
Cain, Matt	2010	Bonds/Bonds/Mays	4.56	3.14	1.42
Nehf, Art	1919	L2: Giants	3.89	2.49	1.40
Plank, Eddie	1908	Athletics' Bender x 2	3.54	2.17	1.37
Mathewson, Christy	1912	Giants: 1912/1931/1950/2011/2020	3.39	2.12	1.27
Marichal, Juan	1965	5 Giants 1909 1929 1965 1992 2012	3.38	2.13	1.25
Grove, Lefty	1932	Athletics' Bender x 2	4.09	2.84	1.25
Cain, Matt	2012	5 Giants 1909 1929 1965 1992 2012	4.04	2.79	1.25
Christopher, Russ	1944	Athletics 1902, 1912, 1981, 1944, 1951	4.22	2.97	1.25
Vickers, Rube	1908	Athletics' Bender x 2	3.36	2.21	1.15
Walker, Bill	1931	Giants: 1912/1931/1950/2011/2020	3.37	2.26	1.11
Hubbell, Carl	1936	Giants Causeway	3.36	2.31	1.05
Mathewson, Christy	1905	Giants 1905, 1921, 1916, 1933, 1957	2.26	1.28	0.98
Barnes, Jesse	1919	L2: Giants	3.37	2.40	0.97
Wiltse, Hooks	1905	Giants 1905, 1921, 1916, 1933, 1957	3.44	2.47	0.97
Plank, Eddie	1909	09,25,33,70,12 Athletics	2.59	1.76	0.83
Mathewson, Christy	1903	SFG 2003-1903-2015-1994-1962	3.01	2.26	0.75
Bender, Chief	1904	OAK 2020-2019-1904-1969-1941	3.62	2.87	0.75
Hudson, Tim	2003	90 MVP Rickey	3.44	2.70	0.74
Hubbell, Carl	1933	Giants 1905, 1921, 1916, 1933, 1957	2.36	1.66	0.70
Grove, Lefty	1930	Puzzle Athletics	3.18	2.54	0.64
Ehmke, Howard	1926	Athletics: 1926/1928/1971/2005/2018	3.45	2.81	0.64
Bumgarner, Madis	2016	Giants 17/38/63/01/16	3.34	2.74	0.60
Plank, Eddie	1901	L2: A's	3.82	3.31	0.51
Bernhard, Bill	1902	Athletics 1902, 1912, 1981, 1944, 1951	2.60	2.15	0.45
Perry, Gaylord	1966	Spitters and Hitters	3.42	2.99	0.43
McCatty, Steve	1981	Athletics 1902, 1912, 1981, 1944, 1951	2.69	2.33	0.36
Plank, Eddie	1913	Bigwig's Athletics (07/13/27/88/01)	2.93	2.60	0.33
Schmidt, Jason	2003	SFG 2003-1903-2015-1994-1962	2.67	2.34	0.33
Perritt, Pol	1918	Gigantes gigantes	2.96	2.74	0.22

League 2 - Team Hitting Total Comparison
.

Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Exp HR	Exp OPS	Act OPS	Diff
Bonds/Bonds/Mays	je3rd	Giants	188	0.982	0.727	-0.255
Gigantes gigantes	Jtpsops	Giants	127	0.982	0.740	-0.242
Giants 17/38/63/01/16	toysboys	Giants	192	0.961	0.748	-0.213
SFG 2003-1903-2015-1994-1962	footballmm11	Giants	179	0.945	0.757	-0.188
5 Giants 1909 1929 1965 1992 2012	BeAllEndAll	Giants	120	0.909	0.730	-0.179
2004, 1934, 1913, 1907, 2007 Giants	jrig21	Giants	103	0.875	0.700	-0.175
Giants 1904, 69, 96,2006, 21	DarthDurron	Giants	157	0.917	0.746	-0.171
Spitters and Hitters	SAKABAKBRG	Giants	113	0.894	0.731	-0.163
L2: Giants	3dayrotation	Giants	89	0.862	0.705	-0.157
Giants: 1912/1931/1950/2011/2020	thejuice6	Giants	100	0.892	0.744	-0.148
Giants Causeway	barracuda3	Giants	107	0.935	0.810	-0.125
Giants 1905, 1921, 1916, 1933, 1957	schwarze	Giants	68	0.870	0.776	-0.094
.
Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Exp HR	Exp OPS	Act OPS	Diff
Oakland Athletics	darny10	Athletics	119	0.903	0.679	-0.224
Athletics 1931 1972 1976 1906 1999	Ribbentrop	Athletics	127	0.878	0.668	-0.210
OAK 2020-2019-1904-1969-1941	footballmm11	Athletics	139	0.883	0.698	-0.185
90 MVP Rickey	ff09	Athletics	150	0.892	0.711	-0.180
Athletics: 1926/1928/1971/2005/2018	thejuice6	Athletics	103	0.886	0.709	-0.177
Puzzle Athletics	calhoop	Athletics	90	0.899	0.728	-0.170
Athletics' Bender x 2	nocomm999	Athletics	98	0.874	0.704	-0.170
Athletics 1911, 1929, 1974, 1994, 2002	mllama54	Athletics	92	0.923	0.755	-0.167
Bigwig's Athletics (07/13/27/88/01)	njbigwig	Athletics	111	0.930	0.784	-0.146
09,25,33,70,12 Athletics	kstober	Athletics	100	0.922	0.783	-0.138
L2: A's	3dayrotation	Athletics	109	0.901	0.769	-0.132
Athletics 1902, 1912, 1981, 1944, 1951	schwarze	Athletics	56	0.869	0.744	-0.125

League 2 - Team Pitching Total Comparison
.

Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Act ERA	Exp ERA	ERA Diff
2004, 1934, 1913, 1907, 2007 Giants	jrig21	Giants	4.84	2.35	2.49
L2: Giants	3dayrotation	Giants	4.46	2.25	2.21
Bonds/Bonds/Mays	je3rd	Giants	4.69	2.67	2.02
Spitters and Hitters	SAKABAKBRG	Giants	4.43	2.43	2.00
Giants 1904, 69, 96,2006, 21	DarthDurron	Giants	4.20	2.20	1.99
Giants Causeway	barracuda3	Giants	3.87	2.12	1.75
Giants 17/38/63/01/16	toysboys	Giants	3.92	2.24	1.68
5 Giants 1909 1929 1965 1992 2012	BeAllEndAll	Giants	3.71	2.15	1.55
Gigantes gigantes	Jtpsops	Giants	4.09	2.61	1.48
Giants 1905, 1921, 1916, 1933, 1957	schwarze	Giants	3.25	1.79	1.46
Giants: 1912/1931/1950/2011/2020	thejuice6	Giants	3.65	2.21	1.44
SFG 2003-1903-2015-1994-1962	footballmm11	Giants	3.63	2.37	1.26
.
Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Act ERA	Exp ERA	ERA Diff
Athletics 1911, 1929, 1974, 1994, 2002	mllama54	Athletics	5.13	2.80	2.33
Athletics 1931 1972 1976 1906 1999	Ribbentrop	Athletics	4.67	2.35	2.31
09,25,33,70,12 Athletics	kstober	Athletics	4.19	1.92	2.26
90 MVP Rickey	ff09	Athletics	4.45	2.23	2.22
Bigwig's Athletics (07/13/27/88/01)	njbigwig	Athletics	4.59	2.54	2.06
Puzzle Athletics	calhoop	Athletics	4.47	2.47	2.00
Oakland Athletics	darny10	Athletics	3.70	1.86	1.84
Athletics' Bender x 2	nocomm999	Athletics	4.08	2.33	1.74
L2: A's	3dayrotation	Athletics	4.65	2.94	1.71
Athletics: 1926/1928/1971/2005/2018	thejuice6	Athletics	4.17	2.47	1.69
OAK 2020-2019-1904-1969-1941	footballmm11	Athletics	3.43	2.07	1.37
Athletics 1902, 1912, 1981, 1944, 1951	schwarze	Athletics	3.72	2.36	1.35

LEAGUE 3 - HITTING
(Min 285 PA to qualify, sorted by biggest underachievers, measured by OPS difference)
.

Leag	Name	Year__	Team Name	Sim OPS	Act OPS	DIFF
3	Thomas, Frank	1994	CHW 1916-1963-1994-1986-1935	0.799	1.216	-0.417
3	Wilson, Hack	1930	Puzzle Cubs	0.819	1.177	-0.358
3	Hornsby, Rogers	1929	1929, 1972, 1957, 1933, 2017 Cubs	0.781	1.138	-0.357
3	Abreu, Jose	2020	South Side Soul	0.649	0.987	-0.338
3	Thomas, Frank	2000	Bigwig's White Sox (09/36/56/71/00)	0.725	1.061	-0.336
3	Belle, Albert	1998	South Side Soul	0.726	1.054	-0.328
3	Hartnett, Gabby	1930	Puzzle Cubs	0.728	1.034	-0.306
3	Abreu, Jose	2014	Dirty Sox from 10/15/58/06/14	0.659	0.964	-0.305
3	English, Woody	1930	Puzzle Cubs	0.636	0.941	-0.305
3	Sosa, Sammy	2001	L3: Cubs	0.870	1.174	-0.304
3	Wilson, Hack	1929	1929, 1972, 1957, 1933, 2017 Cubs	0.748	1.043	-0.295
3	Minoso, Minnie	1956	Bigwig's White Sox (09/36/56/71/00)	0.656	0.950	-0.294
3	Thomas, Frank	1992	White Sox Thomas x 2	0.693	0.975	-0.282
3	Ordonez, Magglio	2000	Bigwig's White Sox (09/36/56/71/00)	0.639	0.917	-0.278
3	Collins, Eddie	1920	White Sox 1913-1920-1923-2003-2010	0.655	0.931	-0.276
3	Appling, Luke	1935	CHW 1916-1963-1994-1986-1935	0.553	0.826	-0.273
3	Baez, Javier	2018	Cubs 23/45/56/18/19	0.612	0.880	-0.268
3	Lollar, Sherm	1955	White Sox 17', 37. 55. 66', 91	0.516	0.782	-0.266
3	Thomas, Frank	1996	WS No Good C 06/26/96/01/49	0.820	1.085	-0.265
3	Kamm, Willie	1924	Two Walsh White Sox	0.441	0.701	-0.260
3	Falk, Bibb	1926	WS No Good C 06/26/96/01/49	0.636	0.892	-0.256
3	Mostil, Johnny	1926	WS No Good C 06/26/96/01/49	0.628	0.882	-0.254
3	Minoso, Minnie	1960	L3: White Sox	0.601	0.855	-0.254
3	Sosa, Sammy	1998	L3: Cubs	0.771	1.024	-0.253
3	Banks, Ernie	1957	1929, 1972, 1957, 1933, 2017 Cubs	0.687	0.939	-0.252
3	Grace, Mark	1998	L3: Cubs	0.623	0.872	-0.249
3	Reynolds, Carl	1930	Two Walsh White Sox	0.723	0.972	-0.249
3	English, Woody	1931	07,31,36,99,14 Cubs	0.556	0.804	-0.248
3	Sosa, Sammy	1999	07,31,36,99,14 Cubs	0.758	1.002	-0.244
3	Evers, Johnny	1912	Cubs 12-19-22-71-22	0.629	0.872	-0.243
3	Collins, Eddie	1923	White Sox 1913-1920-1923-2003-2010	0.666	0.908	-0.242
3	Thomas, Frank	1995	Black Sox Plus 4	0.822	1.060	-0.238
3	Hartnett, Gabby	1935	Cubs 1905, 1935, 1963, 1911, 1979	0.713	0.949	-0.236
3	Demaree, Frank	1936	07,31,36,99,14 Cubs	0.663	0.896	-0.233
3	Rizzo, Anthony	2016	Cubs: 1927/1960/2008/2016/2023	0.697	0.929	-0.232
3	Wilson, Hack	1927	Cubs: 1927/1960/2008/2016/2023	0.749	0.980	-0.231
3	Anderson, Tim	2020	South Side Soul	0.655	0.886	-0.231
3	Hartnett, Gabby	1928	CHC 1909-2021-1928-1984-1967	0.699	0.927	-0.228
3	Fox, Nellie	1957	White Sox 1964, 1957, 1972, 2019, 2002	0.591	0.818	-0.227
3	Appling, Luke	1936	Bigwig's White Sox (09/36/56/71/00)	0.754	0.981	-0.227
3	Banks, Ernie	1958	Cubs 1906, 10, 58, 2002, 05	0.754	0.980	-0.226
3	Melton, Bill	1971	Bigwig's White Sox (09/36/56/71/00)	0.620	0.844	-0.224
3	Hack, Stan	1935	Cubs 1905, 1935, 1963, 1911, 1979	0.618	0.842	-0.224
3	Minoso, Minnie	1957	White Sox 1964, 1957, 1972, 2019, 2002	0.639	0.862	-0.223
3	Banks, Ernie	1959	L3: Cubs	0.747	0.970	-0.223
3	Allen, Dick	1972	White Sox 1964, 1957, 1972, 2019, 2002	0.800	1.023	-0.223
3	Konerko, Paul	2010	White Sox 1913-1920-1923-2003-2010	0.755	0.977	-0.222
3	Sandberg, Ryne	1992	West Side Story	0.660	0.881	-0.221
3	Ordonez, Magglio	2002	White Sox 1964, 1957, 1972, 2019, 2002	0.758	0.978	-0.220
3	Wilson, Hack	1928	CHC 1909-2021-1928-1984-1967	0.777	0.992	-0.215
3	Sandberg, Ryne	1984	CHC 1909-2021-1928-1984-1967	0.673	0.887	-0.214
3	Rizzo, Anthony	2015	5 Cubs 1937 1970 1977 2003 2015	0.685	0.899	-0.214
3	Ordonez, Magglio	2003	White Sox 1913-1920-1923-2003-2010	0.713	0.926	-0.213
3	Fox, Nellie	1951	South Side Soul	0.587	0.797	-0.210
3	Felsch, Happy	1920	White Sox 1913-1920-1923-2003-2010	0.714	0.924	-0.210
3	Banks, Ernie	1960	Cubs: 1927/1960/2008/2016/2023	0.696	0.904	-0.208
3	Ventura, Robin	1992	White Sox Thomas x 2	0.601	0.806	-0.205
3	Minoso, Minnie	1954	White Sox Thomas x 2	0.741	0.946	-0.205
3	Hooper, Harry	1924	Two Walsh White Sox	0.692	0.894	-0.202
3	Grimes, Ray	1922	Cubs 12-19-22-71-22	0.814	1.014	-0.200
3	Herman, Billy	1937	5 Cubs 1937 1970 1977 2003 2015	0.675	0.875	-0.200
3	Dejesus, Ivan	1977	5 Cubs 1937 1970 1977 2003 2015	0.485	0.681	-0.196
3	Bryant, Kris	2016	Cubs: 1927/1960/2008/2016/2023	0.744	0.939	-0.195
3	Jackson, Joe	1920	White Sox 1913-1920-1923-2003-2010	0.839	1.033	-0.194
3	Santo, Ron	1972	1929, 1972, 1957, 1933, 2017 Cubs	0.685	0.878	-0.193
3	Fisk, Carlton	1983	L3: White Sox	0.681	0.873	-0.192
3	Lee, Derrek	2005	Cubs 1906, 10, 58, 2002, 05	0.889	1.080	-0.191
3	Hickman, Jim	1970	5 Cubs 1937 1970 1977 2003 2015	0.811	1.001	-0.190
3	Santo, Ron	1970	5 Cubs 1937 1970 1977 2003 2015	0.659	0.845	-0.186
3	Jackson, Joe	1916	CHW 1916-1963-1994-1986-1935	0.703	0.888	-0.185
3	Vizcaino, Jose	1993	West Side Story	0.514	0.698	-0.184
3	Wilkins, Rick	1993	West Side Story	0.754	0.937	-0.183
3	Cuyler, Kiki	1930	Puzzle Cubs	0.797	0.975	-0.178
3	Herman, Billy	1936	07,31,36,99,14 Cubs	0.685	0.862	-0.177
3	Thomas, Frank	1991	White Sox 17', 37. 55. 66', 91	0.830	1.006	-0.176
3	Zimmerman, Heinie	1912	Cubs 12-19-22-71-22	0.815	0.989	-0.174
3	Collins, Eddie	1924	Two Walsh White Sox	0.722	0.896	-0.174
3	Hack, Stan	1940	West Side Story	0.661	0.834	-0.173
3	Hollocher, Charlie	1922	Cubs 12-19-22-71-22	0.676	0.847	-0.171
3	Bonura, Zeke	1936	Bigwig's White Sox (09/36/56/71/00)	0.740	0.908	-0.168
3	Minoso, Minnie	1951	South Side Soul	0.755	0.922	-0.167
3	Moncada, Yoan	2019	White Sox 1964, 1957, 1972, 2019, 2002	0.748	0.915	-0.167
3	Ramirez, Alexei	2014	Dirty Sox from 10/15/58/06/14	0.550	0.713	-0.163
3	Fisk, Carlton	1990	White Sox Thomas x 2	0.668	0.829	-0.161
3	Ward, Pete	1963	CHW 1916-1963-1994-1986-1935	0.677	0.835	-0.158
3	Weaver, Buck	1920	White Sox 1913-1920-1923-2003-2010	0.630	0.785	-0.155
3	Hartnett, Gabby	1936	07,31,36,99,14 Cubs	0.650	0.804	-0.154
3	Schulte, Frank	1911	Cubs 1905, 1935, 1963, 1911, 1979	0.767	0.918	-0.151
3	Demaree, Frank	1937	5 Cubs 1937 1970 1977 2003 2015	0.717	0.867	-0.150
3	Appling, Luke	1937	White Sox 17', 37. 55. 66', 91	0.697	0.846	-0.149
3	Walls, Lee	1958	Cubs 1906, 10, 58, 2002, 05	0.715	0.863	-0.148
3	Santo, Ron	1966	L3: Cubs	0.803	0.950	-0.147
3	Williams, Billy	1971	Cubs 12-19-22-71-22	0.742	0.888	-0.146
3	Williams, Billy	1970	5 Cubs 1937 1970 1977 2003 2015	0.832	0.977	-0.145
3	Stephenson, Riggs	1927	Cubs: 1927/1960/2008/2016/2023	0.763	0.906	-0.143
3	Collins, Eddie	1919	Black Sox Plus 4	0.663	0.805	-0.142
3	Hartnett, Gabby	1927	Cubs: 1927/1960/2008/2016/2023	0.673	0.815	-0.142
3	Jackson, Joe	1919	Black Sox Plus 4	0.787	0.928	-0.141
3	Hoy, Dummy	1901	WS No Good C 06/26/96/01/49	0.667	0.807	-0.140
3	Collins, Eddie	1915	Dirty Sox from 10/15/58/06/14	0.757	0.896	-0.139
3	Simmons, Al	1933	Black Sox Plus 4	0.715	0.854	-0.139
3	Miller, Hack	1922	Cubs 12-19-22-71-22	0.764	0.900	-0.136
3	Cuyler, Kiki	1931	07,31,36,99,14 Cubs	0.744	0.877	-0.133
3	Johnson, Lance	1995	Black Sox Plus 4	0.634	0.766	-0.132
3	O Farrell, Bob	1923	Cubs 23/45/56/18/19	0.747	0.879	-0.132
3	Baez, Javier	2021	CHC 1909-2021-1928-1984-1967	0.686	0.813	-0.127
3	Stephenson, Riggs	1929	1929, 1972, 1957, 1933, 2017 Cubs	0.883	1.007	-0.124
3	Cavarretta, Phil	1945	Cubs 23/45/56/18/19	0.826	0.949	-0.123
3	Hollocher, Charlie	1918	Puzzle Cubs	0.655	0.776	-0.121
3	Morandini, Mickey	1998	L3: Cubs	0.644	0.765	-0.121
3	Jackson, Joe	1917	White Sox 17', 37. 55. 66', 91	0.687	0.804	-0.117
3	Brock, Lou	1964	West Side Story	0.715	0.822	-0.107
3	Herman, Billy	1935	Cubs 1905, 1935, 1963, 1911, 1979	0.752	0.859	-0.107
3	Appling, Luke	1949	WS No Good C 06/26/96/01/49	0.726	0.833	-0.107
3	Grimm, Charlie	1931	07,31,36,99,14 Cubs	0.745	0.851	-0.106
3	Sheckard, Jimmy	1911	Cubs 1905, 1935, 1963, 1911, 1979	0.717	0.822	-0.105
3	Collins, Eddie	1916	CHW 1916-1963-1994-1986-1935	0.697	0.801	-0.104
3	Hack, Stan	1945	Cubs 23/45/56/18/19	0.721	0.825	-0.104
3	Williams, Billy	1972	1929, 1972, 1957, 1933, 2017 Cubs	0.902	1.004	-0.102
3	Grace, Mark	1993	West Side Story	0.769	0.868	-0.099
3	Wright, Taffy	1940	South Side Soul	0.734	0.833	-0.099
3	Falk, Bibb	1924	Two Walsh White Sox	0.796	0.893	-0.097
3	Adams, Sparky	1927	Cubs: 1927/1960/2008/2016/2023	0.581	0.675	-0.094
3	Fox, Nellie	1960	L3: White Sox	0.630	0.723	-0.093
3	Sheely, Earl	1924	Two Walsh White Sox	0.749	0.837	-0.088
3	Appling, Luke	1940	South Side Soul	0.774	0.862	-0.088
3	Fox, Nellie	1958	Dirty Sox from 10/15/58/06/14	0.622	0.710	-0.088
3	Appling, Luke	1933	Black Sox Plus 4	0.739	0.822	-0.083
3	Pafko, Andy	1945	Cubs 23/45/56/18/19	0.735	0.816	-0.081
3	Fox, Nellie	1954	White Sox Thomas x 2	0.686	0.763	-0.077
3	Bellhorn, Mark	2002	Cubs 1906, 10, 58, 2002, 05	0.809	0.886	-0.077
3	Jackson, Joe	1915	Dirty Sox from 10/15/58/06/14	0.755	0.830	-0.075
3	Phillips, Adolfo	1967	CHC 1909-2021-1928-1984-1967	0.767	0.842	-0.075
3	Kamm, Willie	1926	WS No Good C 06/26/96/01/49	0.707	0.781	-0.074
3	Santo, Ron	1967	CHC 1909-2021-1928-1984-1967	0.835	0.907	-0.072
3	Felsch, Happy	1916	CHW 1916-1963-1994-1986-1935	0.699	0.768	-0.069
3	Slagle, Jimmy	1902	Puzzle Cubs	0.675	0.744	-0.069
3	Tinker, Joe	1911	Cubs 1905, 1935, 1963, 1911, 1979	0.650	0.717	-0.067
3	Sauer, Hank	1952	Cubs 23/45/56/18/19	0.830	0.892	-0.062
3	Felsch, Happy	1917	White Sox 17', 37. 55. 66', 91	0.698	0.755	-0.057
3	Evers, Johnny	1903	Puzzle Cubs	0.652	0.706	-0.054
3	Statz, Jigger	1923	Cubs 23/45/56/18/19	0.761	0.815	-0.054
3	Appling, Luke	1943	L3: White Sox	0.773	0.826	-0.053
3	Fournier, Jack	1915	Dirty Sox from 10/15/58/06/14	0.875	0.920	-0.045
3	Williams, Billy	1964	West Side Story	0.859	0.902	-0.043
3	Galan, Augie	1935	Cubs 1905, 1935, 1963, 1911, 1979	0.825	0.866	-0.041
3	Sullivan, Billy	1908	Two Walsh White Sox	0.422	0.463	-0.041
3	Raines, Tim	1992	White Sox Thomas x 2	0.749	0.785	-0.036
3	Ventura, Robin	1991	White Sox 17', 37. 55. 66', 91	0.779	0.809	-0.030
3	Aparicio, Luis	1968	Two Walsh White Sox	0.610	0.636	-0.026
3	O Farrell, Bob	1922	Cubs 12-19-22-71-22	0.870	0.880	-0.010

LEAGUE 3 - PITCHING
(Min 92 IP to qualify, sorted by biggest underachievers, measured by ERA difference)
.

Player	SN	Team	Sim ERA	Act ERA	ERA Diff
Brown, Mordecai	1906	Cubs 1906, 10, 58, 2002, 05	5.26	1.04	4.22
Warneke, Lon	1933	1929, 1972, 1957, 1933, 2017 Cubs	5.40	2.00	3.40
Prior, Mark	2003	5 Cubs 1937 1970 1977 2003 2015	5.74	2.43	3.31
Vaughn, Hippo	1918	Puzzle Cubs	4.91	1.74	3.17
Root, Charlie	1933	1929, 1972, 1957, 1933, 2017 Cubs	5.63	2.60	3.03
Altrock, Nick	1905	White Sox Thomas x 2	4.86	1.88	2.98
Keuchel, Dallas	2020	South Side Soul	4.89	1.99	2.90
Hacker, Warren	1952	Cubs 23/45/56/18/19	5.37	2.58	2.79
Reulbach, Ed	1908	L3: Cubs	4.81	2.03	2.78
Callahan, Nixey	1901	WS No Good C 06/26/96/01/49	5.15	2.42	2.73
Brown, Mordecai	1910	Cubs 1906, 10, 58, 2002, 05	4.55	1.86	2.69
Pizarro, Juan	1964	W.Sox 1964, 1957, 1972, 2019, 2002	5.21	2.56	2.65
Scott, Jim	1910	Dirty Sox from 10/15/58/06/14	5.02	2.43	2.59
Hendricks, Kyle	2020	Puzzle Cubs	5.46	2.88	2.58
Smith, Frank	1904	L3: White Sox	4.57	2.09	2.48
Vaughn, Hippo	1919	Cubs 12-19-22-71-22	4.23	1.79	2.44
Passeau, Claude	1945	Cubs 23/45/56/18/19	4.88	2.46	2.42
White, Doc	1910	Dirty Sox from 10/15/58/06/14	5.04	2.66	2.38
Wood, Wilbur	1972	W.Sox 1964, 1957, 1972, 2019, 2002	4.88	2.51	2.37
Taylor, Jack	1902	Puzzle Cubs	3.69	1.33	2.36
Altrock, Nick	1906	WS No Good C 06/26/96/01/49	4.38	2.06	2.32
Lester, Jon	2015	5 Cubs 1937 1970 1977 2003 2015	5.64	3.34	2.30
Pierce, Billy	1955	White Sox 17', 37. 55. 66', 91	4.26	1.97	2.29
Maddux, Greg	1992	West Side Story	4.46	2.18	2.28
Reulbach, Ed	1907	07,31,36,99,14 Cubs	3.95	1.69	2.26
Pfiester, Jack	1908	L3: Cubs	4.26	2.00	2.26
Hendricks, Kyle	2016	Cubs: 1927/1960/2008/2016/2023	4.32	2.13	2.19
Ellsworth, Dick	1963	Cubs 1905, 1935, 1963, 1911, 1979	4.29	2.11	2.18
Jenkins, Fergie	1970	5 Cubs 1937 1970 1977 2003 2015	5.57	3.39	2.18
Cicotte, Eddie	1917	White Sox 17', 37. 55. 66', 91	3.61	1.53	2.08
Alexander, Pete	1923	Cubs 23/45/56/18/19	5.25	3.19	2.06
Pfiester, Jack	1907	07,31,36,99,14 Cubs	3.20	1.15	2.05
Root, Charlie	1929	1929, 1972, 1957, 1933, 2017 Cubs	5.40	3.47	1.93
Cicotte, Eddie	1919	Black Sox Plus 4	3.66	1.82	1.84
Pfiester, Jack	1906	Cubs 1906, 10, 58, 2002, 05	3.31	1.51	1.80
White, Doc	1905	White Sox Thomas x 2	3.55	1.76	1.79
Walsh, Ed	1911	Two Walsh White Sox	3.98	2.22	1.76
Brown, Mordecai	1907	07,31,36,99,14 Cubs	3.10	1.39	1.71
Jenkins, Fergie	1972	1929, 1972, 1957, 1933, 2017 Cubs	4.89	3.20	1.69
Russell, Reb	1913	White Sox 1913-1920-1923-2003-2010	3.58	1.90	1.68
Steele, Justin	2023	Cubs: 1927/1960/2008/2016/2023	4.74	3.06	1.68
Cicotte, Eddie	1913	White Sox 1913-1920-1923-2003-2010	3.26	1.58	1.68
Walsh, Ed	1907	L3: White Sox	3.22	1.60	1.62
Jackson, Larry	1963	Cubs 1905, 1935, 1963, 1911, 1979	4.17	2.55	1.62
Reulbach, Ed	1906	Cubs 1906, 10, 58, 2002, 05	3.27	1.65	1.62
Peters, Gary	1966	White Sox 17', 37. 55. 66', 91	3.57	1.98	1.59
Owen, Frank	1905	White Sox Thomas x 2	3.63	2.10	1.53
Lundgren, Carl	1907	07,31,36,99,14 Cubs	2.67	1.17	1.50
Griffith, Clark	1901	WS No Good C 06/26/96/01/49	4.17	2.67	1.50
Scott, Jim	1913	White Sox 1913-1920-1923-2003-2010	3.35	1.90	1.45
Lester, Jon	2016	Cubs: 1927/1960/2008/2016/2023	3.85	2.44	1.41
Taylor, Jack	1903	Puzzle Cubs	3.85	2.45	1.40
Pizarro, Juan	1963	CHW 1916-1963-1994-1986-1935	3.79	2.39	1.40
Walsh, Ed	1906	WS No Good C 06/26/96/01/49	3.27	1.88	1.39
Jenkins, Fergie	1971	Cubs 12-19-22-71-22	4.12	2.77	1.35
Smith, Frank	1909	Bigwig's White Sox (09/36/56/71/00)	3.15	1.80	1.35
Peters, Gary	1967	South Side Soul	3.62	2.28	1.34
Wood, Wilbur	1971	Bigwig's White Sox (09/36/56/71/00)	3.20	1.91	1.29
Rush, Bob	1952	Cubs 23/45/56/18/19	3.97	2.70	1.27
Overall, Orval	1908	L3: Cubs	3.19	1.92	1.27
Fisher, Eddie	1965	Black Sox Plus 4	3.66	2.40	1.26
White, Doc	1906	WS No Good C 06/26/96/01/49	2.76	1.52	1.24
Walsh, Ed	1910	Dirty Sox from 10/15/58/06/14	2.48	1.27	1.21
Reulbach, Ed	1905	Cubs 1905, 1935, 1963, 1911, 1979	2.62	1.42	1.20
Stratton, Monty	1937	White Sox 17', 37. 55. 66', 91	3.59	2.40	1.19
Smith, Frank	1908	Two Walsh White Sox	3.21	2.03	1.18
Walsh, Ed	1908	Two Walsh White Sox	2.59	1.42	1.17
Smith, Frank	1905	White Sox Thomas x 2	3.29	2.13	1.16
Overall, Orval	1909	CHC 1909-2021-1928-1984-1967	2.57	1.42	1.15
Alexander, Pete	1919	Cubs 12-19-22-71-22	2.84	1.72	1.12
Walsh, Ed	1909	Bigwig's White Sox (09/36/56/71/00)	2.53	1.41	1.12
Brown, Mordecai	1905	Cubs 1905, 1935, 1963, 1911, 1979	3.23	2.17	1.06
Rogovin, Saul	1951	South Side Soul	3.54	2.48	1.06
Horlen, Joe	1967	South Side Soul	3.04	2.06	0.98
Owen, Frank	1904	L3: White Sox	2.91	1.94	0.97
Weimer, Jake	1904	West Side Story	2.86	1.91	0.95
Brown, Mordecai	1908	L3: Cubs	2.37	1.47	0.90
Reulbach, Ed	1909	CHC 1909-2021-1928-1984-1967	2.64	1.78	0.86
Lynn, Lance	2021	Black Sox Plus 4	3.52	2.69	0.83
Brown, Mordecai	1909	CHC 1909-2021-1928-1984-1967	2.10	1.31	0.79
Brown, Mordecai	1904	West Side Story	2.61	1.87	0.74
Russell, Reb	1916	CHW 1916-1963-1994-1986-1935	3.13	2.42	0.71
Darvish, Yu	2020	Puzzle Cubs	2.71	2.01	0.70
Peters, Gary	1963	CHW 1916-1963-1994-1986-1935	2.99	2.33	0.66
Williams, Lefty	1919	Black Sox Plus 4	3.21	2.64	0.57
Arrieta, Jake	2015	5 Cubs 1937 1970 1977 2003 2015	2.31	1.77	0.54
Pierce, Billy	1957	W.Sox 1964, 1957, 1972, 2019, 2002	3.73	3.26	0.47
Douglas, Phil	1919	Cubs 12-19-22-71-22	2.49	2.03	0.46
Lundgren, Carl	1904	West Side Story	3.00	2.60	0.40
Arrieta, Jake	2016	Cubs: 1927/1960/2008/2016/2023	3.49	3.10	0.39
Overall, Orval	1907	07,31,36,99,14 Cubs	1.96	1.68	0.28
Horlen, Joe	1964	W.Sox 1964, 1957, 1972, 2019, 2002	1.94	1.88	0.06
Altrock, Nick	1904	L3: White Sox	2.59	2.96	-0.37

League 3 - Team Hitting Total Comparison
.

Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Exp HR	Exp OPS	Act OPS	Diff
1929, 1972, 1957, 1933, 2017 Cubs	jrig21	Cubs	159	0.963	0.747	-0.216
Puzzle Cubs	calhoop	Cubs	86	0.899	0.703	-0.196
L3: Cubs	3dayrotation	Cubs	158	0.900	0.722	-0.178
Cubs 1906, 10, 58, 2002, 05	DarthDurron	Cubs	148	0.900	0.722	-0.178
07,31,36,99,14 Cubs	kstober	Cubs	77	0.879	0.705	-0.175
Cubs: 1927/1960/2008/2016/2023	thejuice6	Cubs	113	0.875	0.701	-0.174
5 Cubs 1937 1970 1977 2003 2015	BeAllEndAll	Cubs	105	0.877	0.715	-0.162
CHC 1909-2021-1928-1984-1967	footballmm11	Cubs	129	0.885	0.728	-0.157
Cubs 12-19-22-71-22	redcped	Cubs	56	0.882	0.738	-0.144
Cubs 1905, 1935, 1963, 1911, 1979	schwarze	Cubs	52	0.852	0.713	-0.139
West Side Story	Taxman2008	Cubs	103	0.861	0.723	-0.137
Cubs 23/45/56/18/19	toysboys	Cubs	94	0.866	0.755	-0.111
.
Team Name	Owner	Franchise__	Exp HR	Exp OPS	Act OPS	Diff
Bigwig's White Sox (09/36/56/71/00)	njbigwig	White Sox	121	0.925	0.701	-0.224
White Sox 1913-1920-1923-2003-2010	pedrocerrano	White Sox	70	0.893	0.685	-0.208
South Side Soul	Bill_James47	White Sox	96	0.877	0.676	-0.201
White Sox 1964, 1957, 1972, 2019, 2002	schwarze	White Sox	111	0.866	0.679	-0.187
CHW 1916-1963-1994-1986-1935	footballmm11	White Sox	72	0.868	0.689	-0.179
WS No Good C 06/26/96/01/49	firesalt	White Sox	54	0.864	0.690	-0.174
White Sox Thomas x 2	nocomm999	White Sox	71	0.848	0.676	-0.172
Dirty Sox from 10/15/58/06/14	ejstockman	White Sox	73	0.834	0.676	-0.158
Two Walsh White Sox	pmars2001	White Sox	41	0.794	0.645	-0.149
Black Sox Plus 4	SteveIzzy	White Sox	81	0.846	0.701	-0.145
White Sox 17', 37. 55. 66', 91	glowguy	White Sox	72	0.829	0.709	-0.120
L3: White Sox	3dayrotation	White Sox	47	0.770	0.658	-0.111

League 3 - Team Pitching Total Comparison
.

Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Act ERA	Exp ERA	ERA Diff
1929, 1972, 1957, 1933, 2017 Cubs	jrig21	Cubs	5.83	2.87	2.96
Cubs 1906, 10, 58, 2002, 05	DarthDurron	Cubs	4.01	1.92	2.09
5 Cubs 1937 1970 1977 2003 2015	BeAllEndAll	Cubs	4.78	2.69	2.09
Puzzle Cubs	calhoop	Cubs	4.14	2.06	2.08
Cubs 23/45/56/18/19	toysboys	Cubs	4.45	2.58	1.87
L3: Cubs	3dayrotation	Cubs	3.88	2.09	1.80
Cubs: 1927/1960/2008/2016/2023	thejuice6	Cubs	4.51	2.76	1.76
Cubs 1905, 1935, 1963, 1911, 1979	schwarze	Cubs	3.72	2.07	1.65
07,31,36,99,14 Cubs	kstober	Cubs	3.21	1.65	1.56
Cubs 12-19-22-71-22	redcped	Cubs	3.48	2.12	1.36
CHC 1909-2021-1928-1984-1967	footballmm11	Cubs	2.86	1.73	1.13
West Side Story	Taxman2008	Cubs	3.30	2.27	1.03
.
Team Name	Owner	Franchise__	Act ERA	Exp ERA	ERA Diff
White Sox Thomas x 2	nocomm999	White Sox	3.99	1.99	2.00
White Sox 17', 37. 55. 66', 91	glowguy	White Sox	3.95	1.99	1.95
White Sox 1913-1920-1923-2003-2010	pedrocerrano	White Sox	3.85	2.12	1.73
Dirty Sox from 10/15/58/06/14	ejstockman	White Sox	3.68	1.95	1.73
WS No Good C 06/26/96/01/49	firesalt	White Sox	3.79	2.18	1.61
White Sox 1964, 1957, 1972, 2019, 2002	schwarze	White Sox	4.08	2.56	1.52
Two Walsh White Sox	pmars2001	White Sox	3.38	1.90	1.48
Bigwig's White Sox (09/36/56/71/00)	njbigwig	White Sox	3.44	2.04	1.39
South Side Soul	Bill_James47	White Sox	3.36	2.02	1.34
Black Sox Plus 4	SteveIzzy	White Sox	3.46	2.32	1.14
L3: White Sox	3dayrotation	White Sox	3.26	2.17	1.09
CHW 1916-1963-1994-1986-1935	footballmm11	White Sox	3.25	2.44	0.81

I thought when the season started that my Yankees team was really good. Seeing all five Starters in the Top 19 of pitchers who are underachieving makes sense. What a pitiful excuse for a pitching staff...

Posted by thejuice6 on 3/11/2024 3:34:00 PM (view original):
I thought when the season started that my Yankees team was really good. Seeing all five Starters in the Top 19 of pitchers who are underachieving makes sense. What a pitiful excuse for a pitching staff...

Playing your home games in Yankee Stadium III was probably not the best choice. Your expected HR frequency for your batters is below average so playing in a high-HR stadium is hurting your pitchers *more* than helping your hitters. In fact, your pitching staff is ranked as the worst in the league in HR prevention. Also, your team's "expected whip" is the third worst among the twelve Yankee teams, and your defense has the second most errors in the league (double the league average) so the combination of allowing lots of baserunners & allowing lots of HRs is a bad recipe for success.