Thanks for the responses...they've definitely given some things to think about. However, I do have a follow up question: do you ever tweak these settings during the regular season? And if so, how often do you do that? At the moment I am tweaking things 3-4 times a season, which has provided improved results but it's still not quite where I want it to be.

For bullpen I never tweak the settings just SuA, SuB or RHSP (aka I don't want you pitching unless everyone else is exhausted)
I'll adjust my starters pull rating all the time based off of how they are doing. Really well, 1-2 average 3. Rookie or low control is a 5.

Posted by hockey1984 on 7/9/2020 2:13:00 PM (view original):
For bullpen I never tweak the settings just SuA, SuB or RHSP (aka I don't want you pitching unless everyone else is exhausted)
I'll adjust my starters pull rating all the time based off of how they are doing. Really well, 1-2 average 3. Rookie or low control is a 5.

I have been using a similar system when I adjust settings, but have been doing it for both SP and RP. I'll give doing SPs only a shot and see how it goes...