Posted by tangplay on 10/8/2020 1:14:00 PM (view original):
Posted by dahsdebater on 10/8/2020 12:19:00 PM (view original):
Posted by coreander on 10/8/2020 9:46:00 AM (view original):
On a scale of 1 to Donald Trump how sexist did you find Mike Pence to be last night?
All of his interruptions and mansplaining reaffirmed my hatred for toxic masculinity.
All in all, I'm beginning to think of Kamala as less of a centrist, which is good.
This is the stupidest popular take, so no shock that you've gone straight there.
Go watch Pence's VP debate from 2016. If anything, he did more "mansplaining" against his white male opponent in that debate. Nobody called it toxic masculinity when the other participant wasn't a woman. What's more, Harris did THE SAME THING in THE SAME DEBATE and nobody's calling it "toxic femininity." In fact, I heard some of the same people who were criticizing Pence for "mansplaining" praising Harris for explaining things clearly, not just for Pence but for the general audience.
This is the problem I have with modern progressives. They want women and minorities to be treated equally until it's inconvenient, and then they want them to be treated differently. I'm totally on board with feminism through roughly the 70s. Since then things have really gone off the rails.
This is actually a really interesting topic. Toxic masculinity is definitely a thing. Does that mean that we need to approach the issue in the same way that core does? No. But the discussion is there to be had.
Obviously toxic masculinity is a thing, although the nomenclature seems a bit weird (/sexist) to me. I would argue, for example, that if you look into the personal and professional life of Hope Solo that she has clearly and repeatedly exhibited the characteristics that would generally fall under that title. The name toxic masculinity inherently presumes characteristic masculine and feminine characteristics, which the people who spend the most time talking about it otherwise reject. But whatever - we agree that the idea commonly called toxic masculinity does, in fact, exist.
I think it's very likely that we'd differ significantly in how we define toxic masculinity, but I also think that under both of our definitions Mike Pence doesn't have a whole lot of it. All of this is somewhat outside of the point that Pence and Harris behaved very similarly in the debate and we have a large community praising one of them and denouncing the other for nearly identical behavior. I just think if we take the political dimension out of it - people who like to talk about toxic masculinity are generally not fans of Mike Pence - step back, and take a look at Pence, he is far, far, far from almost anybody's definition of what toxic masculinity looks like.
Further, this has little to do with my original point that nobody criticized Pence's behavior in this way when he was debating Tim Kaine. I don't buy into the idea that it is somehow progressive and open-minded to demand that he treat Kamala differently because she's a woman. And by the way, she demonstrated amply that she's quite strong enough to stand up for herself and certainly didn't need to be treated differently.