The Final Juice Tournament: Round 3 - Top 20 Picks Topic

LG 2 - NLE 1914 Chicago Whales
3/19/2023 2:36 AM
1954 Cleveland Indians - League 5, NL Central
3/19/2023 8:53 AM
League 4, AL Central- 1948 Cleveland Indians

League 10, AL East - 2016 Chicago Cubs
3/19/2023 9:25 AM
League 9 - NL Central - 2002 Boston Red Sox
3/19/2023 10:08 AM
Lg. 3, AL East - 1933 NY Giants
3/19/2023 11:03 AM
League 7 NL East

1975 Cincinnati Reds
3/19/2023 11:18 AM
Doubling down on the 1954 Cleveland Indians, this time in League 5 NL West.
3/19/2023 12:20 PM
Poor league 8.... The years 1986-98 getting no love.
3/19/2023 12:23 PM
I’ll take the other 1948 Cleveland Indians (League 4 - AL West)
3/19/2023 6:02 PM
Posted by thejuice6 on 3/19/2023 6:07:00 PM (view original):

The Top 20 Round Two Team Owners and their picks:

(01) BARRACUDA3 - 1927 New York Yankees (League 3 - N.L. East)
(02) BARRACUDA3 - 1939 New York Yankees (League 4 - N.L. East)
(03) PEDROCERRANO - 1903 Cleveland Naps (League 1 - N.L. East)
(04) BARRACUDA3 - 2019 Houston Astros (League 10 - A.L. Central)
(05) PEDROCERRANO - 1969 Baltimore Orioles (League 6 - A.L. East)
(06) SCHWARZE - 1981 Houston Astros (League 7 - A.L. East)
(07) SCHWARZE - 1961 New York Yankees (League 5 - A.L. West)

(08) REDCPED - 2015 Los Angeles Dodgers (League 10 - N.L. West)
(09) CALHOOP - 1931 Philadelphia Athletics (League 3 - N.L. West)
(10) BARRACUDA3 - 1906 Chicago Cubs (League 1 - N.L. Central)
(11) BARRACUDA3 - 1937 New York Yankees (League 3 - A.L. West)
(12) TOYSBOYS - 1914 Chicago Whales (League 2 - N.L. East)
(13) BARRACUDA3 - 1954 Cleveland Indians (League 5 - N.L. Central)
(14) SCHWARZE - 1948 Cleveland Indians (League 4 - A.L. Central)
(15) SCHWARZE - 2016 Chicago Cubs (League 10 - A.L. East)
(16) KSTOBER - 2002 Boston Red Sox (League 9 - N.L. Central)
(17) NOCOMM999 - 1933 New York Giants (League 3 - A.L. East)
(18) GLOWGUY - 1975 Cincinnati Reds (League 7 - N.L. East)
(19) KSTOBER - 1954 Cleveland Indians (League 5 - N.L. West)
(20) FOOTBALLMM11 - 1948 Cleveland Indians (League 4 - AL West)



Thru 27 games, the top 20 picks are a robust 269-271. This may turn around a bit as this group is a combined 51-63 in 1-run games.
4/10/2023 11:26 AM
Posted by schwarze on 4/10/2023 11:26:00 AM (view original):
Posted by thejuice6 on 3/19/2023 6:07:00 PM (view original):

The Top 20 Round Two Team Owners and their picks:

(01) BARRACUDA3 - 1927 New York Yankees (League 3 - N.L. East)
(02) BARRACUDA3 - 1939 New York Yankees (League 4 - N.L. East)
(03) PEDROCERRANO - 1903 Cleveland Naps (League 1 - N.L. East)
(04) BARRACUDA3 - 2019 Houston Astros (League 10 - A.L. Central)
(05) PEDROCERRANO - 1969 Baltimore Orioles (League 6 - A.L. East)
(06) SCHWARZE - 1981 Houston Astros (League 7 - A.L. East)
(07) SCHWARZE - 1961 New York Yankees (League 5 - A.L. West)

(08) REDCPED - 2015 Los Angeles Dodgers (League 10 - N.L. West)
(09) CALHOOP - 1931 Philadelphia Athletics (League 3 - N.L. West)
(10) BARRACUDA3 - 1906 Chicago Cubs (League 1 - N.L. Central)
(11) BARRACUDA3 - 1937 New York Yankees (League 3 - A.L. West)
(12) TOYSBOYS - 1914 Chicago Whales (League 2 - N.L. East)
(13) BARRACUDA3 - 1954 Cleveland Indians (League 5 - N.L. Central)
(14) SCHWARZE - 1948 Cleveland Indians (League 4 - A.L. Central)
(15) SCHWARZE - 2016 Chicago Cubs (League 10 - A.L. East)
(16) KSTOBER - 2002 Boston Red Sox (League 9 - N.L. Central)
(17) NOCOMM999 - 1933 New York Giants (League 3 - A.L. East)
(18) GLOWGUY - 1975 Cincinnati Reds (League 7 - N.L. East)
(19) KSTOBER - 1954 Cleveland Indians (League 5 - N.L. West)
(20) FOOTBALLMM11 - 1948 Cleveland Indians (League 4 - AL West)



Thru 27 games, the top 20 picks are a robust 269-271. This may turn around a bit as this group is a combined 51-63 in 1-run games.
Remarkably, the combined record of the Top 20 draft teams is dragged down considerably by the 2nd and 3rd picks in the draft. My '37 Yankees are 6 games under .500, while pedrocerrano's '03 Naps are 10 games under .500, so the other 18 teams are a combined 14 games over .500 (which admittedly still isn't great). More remarkably, the 2nd and 3rd picks are both OVERPERFORMING their expected winning percentages: in my team's case .393 vs .365, and in pedro's .321 vs .263.
4/10/2023 11:40 AM
Pick #15 (2016 Cubs) is clearly the worst pick of this group. Their 8-20 record is terrible. Even when you remove the 1-7 in 1-run games, it's still a below .500 team. I knew it was a bad pick when the other 2016 Cubs went with the tenth pick in League 10.

My other choice here was the 1906 Cubs, which I ended up with anyway.
4/10/2023 11:52 AM
◂ Prev 12
The Final Juice Tournament: Round 3 - Top 20 Picks Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.