Neighbor League Roster Check Forum Topic

Poisons

$79,785,967

Shea Stadium

1936 Pittsburgh Pirates (6)


OF - Lloyd Waner
OF - Paul Waner
P - Cy Blanton
P - Red Lucas
P - Waite Hoyt
P - Guy Bush

1956 Kansas City Athletics (6)

1b - Vic Power
2b - Clete Boyer
SS - Joe Demaestri
OF - Enos Slaughter
P - Bill Harrington
P - Tom Lasorda

1936 Chicago White Sox (6)

C - Luke Sewell
C - Frank Grube
2b - Tony Piet
3b - Jimmie D ykes
OF - Mule Haas
OF - Dixie Walker

1976 New York Mets (7)

1b - Ed Kranepool
3b - Wayne Garrett
SS - Mike Phillips
P - Tom Seaver
P - Jerry Koosman
P - Jon Matlack
P - Ken Sanders
8/8/2023 2:28 AM (edited)
no feller
$79,974,133
Stadium: League Park (II)
1946 red sox (6)
Pesky, Johnny SS
Dimaggio, Dom OF
Wagner, Charlie P
Brown, Mace P
Klinger, Bob P
Hughson, Tex P
1966 mets (6)
Hunt, Ron 2B
Hiller, Chuck 2B
Boyer, Ken 3B
Jones, Cleon OF
Stuart, Dick 1B
McGraw, Tug P
1946 indians (6)
Hegan, Jim C
Ross, Don 3B
Becker, Heinz 1B
Center, Pete P
Harder, Mel P
Embree, Red P
1926 reds (7)
Picinich, Val C
Emmer, Frank SS
Roush, Edd OF
Bressler, Rube OF
Christensen, Cuckoo OF
Mays, Carl P
Donohue, Pete P
8/7/2023 12:31 AM
Loving that folks are rostering the likes of Tom Lasorda and Dick Stuart. What a league!
8/7/2023 12:37 AM
whalers roster is good
8/7/2023 1:57 AM
Seay's roster is good.

Whalers has corrected me.

His roster is compliant with the rules.

Whether it is good or not remains to be seen.
8/7/2023 11:11 AM
Jon's roster is good
8/7/2023 6:23 PM
redcpeds roster is good
8/7/2023 7:36 PM
Revised roster is posted
8/8/2023 2:50 AM
Bronx Cheers
Payroll: $79,944,223
Stadium: Yankee Stadium (I)

1946 New York Yankees - 7
  • Aaron Robinson (C)
  • Frankie Crosetti (SS)
  • Charlie Keller (OF)
  • Spud Chandler (P)
  • Bill Bevens (P)
  • Randy Gumpert (P)
  • Al Gettel (P)
1946 St. Louis Browns - 6
  • Hank Helf (C)
  • Vern Stephens (SS)
  • Glenn McQuillen (OF)
  • Jack Kramer (P)
  • Tom Ferrick (P)
  • Ox Miller (P)
1956 Baltimore Orioles - 6
  • Bob Boyd (1B)
  • Billy Gardner (2B)
  • Bobby Adams (3B)
  • Bob Nieman (OF)
  • Hoot Evers (OF)
  • Mike Fornieles (P)
1926 Philadelphia A's
  • Jim Poole (1B)
  • Max Bishop (2B)
  • Jimmy D y k e s (3B)
  • Al Simmons (OF)
  • Howard Ehmke (P)
  • Fred Heimach (P)
This is my third time playing this format, and I've had good success in the past two leagues: one team won 100 games, the other won the World Series. That said, I'm feeling less confident about this team than I did about either of the previous versions.

The screw picks were very effective this time. I took the 46 Yankees for their pitching, thinking that I would be able to focus on offense in the 4th round, but the 46 Browns and the 56 Orioles had barely any pitching worthy of a roster spot, so I needed a team in the 4th round with some insurance pitching in case Spud Chandler got daggered. The 26 A's were the best compromise pick, but I didn't come away with as much offensive firepower as I would have liked.

I think this team will pitch, especially playing half their games in the old Yankee Stadium. But will they hit? On days when we field our best possible lineup, I like our chances. But with only Simmons and Keller having in excess of 575 PAs, our depth is going to be tested early and often, and I don't have much confidence in our bench bats.

For this team to make the playoffs, Chandler needs to be a Cy Young contender, and Simmons and Keller need to put up Silver Slugger seasons. Otherwise, this has the look of a .500 club.
8/8/2023 11:04 PM
3dayrotation's roster is good
8/9/2023 1:00 AM
jwillis roster is good
8/9/2023 1:37 AM
razorclams roster is good
8/9/2023 12:42 PM
79 970014
76 Reds
C Johnny Bench
3b Pete Rose
Of George Foster
2b Joe Morgan
P Manny Sarmiento
P Pat Zachery
P Rawly Eastwick


76 Expos
2b Pepe Frias
1b Andre Thornton
Of Pepe Manguel
SS Tim Foli
P Steve Rogers
P Fred Scherman

36 Bees
C Bill Lewis
Of Tommy Thompson
3b Mickey Haslin
Of Wally Berger
P Guy Bush
P Roy Weir

76 Pirates
1b Ed Kirkpatrick
SS Mario Mendoza
Of Bill Robinson
P John Candelaria
P Bruce Kison
P Kent Tekulve

I don't like picking first as you also get the worst team available which was very difficult find 5 players that could be somewhat useful. I will have a potent offence led by the Big Red Machine. The pitching has lots of holes but the bullpen should be decent. If I am a 500 team I have done well considering the limitations
8/10/2023 7:32 AM (edited)
Washington Red Sox

$79,942,979

Griffith Stadium

1976 Boston Red Sox (7)

C. Carlton Fisk
C. Bob Montgomery
1B. Carl Yastrzemski
SS. Rick Burleson
P. Luis Tiant
P. Fergie Jenkins
P. Reggie Cleveland

1926 Boston Braves (6)
2B. Doc Gautreau
2B. Eddie Moore
OF. Eddie Brown
OF. Les Mann
OF. Frank Wilson
P. Foster Edwards

1956 Washington Senators (6)
1B. Pete Runnels
SS. Jerry Snyder
3B. Harmon Killebrew
OF. Roy Sievers
OF. Jim Lemon
P. Bud Byerly

1976 Los Angeles Dodgers (6)
3B. Ron Cey
P. Burt Hooton
P. Rick Rhoden
P. Doug Rau
P. Charlie Hough
P. Elias Sosa
8/10/2023 1:59 AM (edited)
$79,914,146
Yankee Stadium

1926 Brooklyn Robins (6)
Babe Herman 1B $4,105,733
Jack Fournier 1B $1,714,449
Jerry Standaert 2B $836,359
Jesse Petty P $8,230,360
Rube Ehrhardt P $1,976,752
George Boehler P $419,897

1936 St Louis Browns (6)
Beau Bell OF $5,600,004
Ed Coleman OF $823,337
Ray Pepper OF $564,551
Ivy Andrews P $4,175,569
Glenn Liebhardt P $529,057
Roy Mahaffey P $728,237

1936 NY Yankees (6)
Jack Saltzgaver 3B $318,562
George Selkirk OF $5,285,794
Red Ruffing P $8,086,744
Monte Pearson P $6,376,256
Pat Malone P $3,501,466
Johnny Murphy P $2,039,454

1956 Detroit Tigers (7)
Red Wilson C $2,670,758
Frank House C $1,998,683
Frank Bolling 2B $2,639,614
Ray Boone 3B $5,146,837
Harvey Kuenn SS $5,248,196
Jim Brideweser SS $817,870
Charlie Maxwell OF $6,079,607
8/10/2023 9:02 AM
◂ Prev 123 Next ▸
Neighbor League Roster Check Forum Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.