Clearly, either strategy can be successful. bheid408 and ejstockman were the two owners who relied most heavily on their drafted players (60.9%) and they both won 85+ games. pmars 2001 won 96 games and had the 6th highest drafted-player%. I was tied with the lowest % at 37.3% and won 97 games, so my strategy of relying on teammates paid off. ff09 won 92 games with a 50/50 split (but his hitting/pitching split was the most pronounced).
Version 2 should be interesting, especially since we added the DH (i.e., one less scrub = one more drafted player that will be needed to use)