33 Points in 1 OT Topic

And now I'm falling into the same trap. Time to go........
1/25/2010 11:19 AM
Quote: Originally posted by fd343ny on 1/25/2010folks should know that they use pseudo random for Penn State home games - which may explain this result
That's just because Paterno won't let them use the real thing for basketball.
1/25/2010 11:46 AM
Quote: Originally posted by colonels19 on 1/25/2010Not going to say that, but that's what I've always contended, thus it wouldn't just be some out of the blue excuse for me.

Out of the blue, no. 'Excuse', definitely.
1/25/2010 12:08 PM
Quote: Originally Posted By emy1013 on 1/25/2010
Quote: Originally Posted By colonels19 on 1/25/2010
There's no spiel, please.



Keep trying to convince everybody of that. Anyone who has followed those nightmares of threads closely knows different. In fact, it's been blatantly obvious.


I've believed whole-heartedly in everything I've posted, seriously. You guys want to keep mentioning and digging at me like I don't know what I'm talking about, then I in turn am going to keep you guys on your heels as well, because as I've said before, if you think saying enough "bad stuff" about colonels is going to make me leave, it isn't, it only makes me stronger and go harder. So like I said, its your choice....just make sure you can handle the choice you make....that's all I'm saying.
1/25/2010 12:33 PM
Quote: Originally Posted By a_in_the_b on 1/25/2010
Quote: Originally posted by colonels19 on 1/25/2010 Not going to say that, but that's what I've always contended, thus it wouldn't just be some out of the blue excuse for me.

Out of the blue, no. 'Excuse', definitely.
For the 7000th time, if you can't see how the sim can/should be different than real life, then I'm quite simply wasting my time with an idiot.
1/25/2010 12:34 PM
the SIM of course is different from real life in a host of ways, and rightly so

on the other hand, the existence of a certain result in real life, indeed within days of a supposedly noteworthy event in the SIM, does make the event in the SIM seem a bunch less odd or extreme or whatever

one would think that someone who - for example - urged a certain approach to rankings and pointed and his own rankings of teams in real life - would see that real life and its events can be relevant to discussions of the SIM -

odd that one would call someone an "idiot" for reasoning that parallels one's own
1/25/2010 1:00 PM
I'm calling anyone who doesn't think that the sim can/should be different from real life an idiot, because if you don't/can't understand that there are many different factors in each "game" that determine outcomes, what other conclusion can you come to?

The rankings thing is really apples to oranges. WIS uses what RL uses (human polls and RPI/SOS) and if used/applied properly, it would work just fine. There's no doubt in my mind that if my RL rankings were used here, that you would see the same quality here as you do in my RL rankings because nothing will have changed in the implementation.
1/25/2010 1:06 PM
Quote: Originally Posted By colonels19 on 1/25/2010

I'm calling anyone who doesn't think that the sim can/should be different from real life an idiot, because if you don't/can't understand that there are many different factors in each "game" that determine outcomes, what other conclusion can you come to?

The rankings thing is really apples to oranges. WIS uses what RL uses (human polls and RPI/SOS) and if used/applied properly, it would work just fine. There's no doubt in my mind that if my RL rankings were used here, that you would see the same quality here as you do in my RL rankings because nothing will have changed in the implementation.

and who specifically said he "doesn't think that the sim can/should be different from real life"

now please be specific because you are calling folks idiots and putting words in their mouths.....an odd combination if you think about it

and to be 100% clear, colonel - I have no problem with you personally, but your fast a loose use of words and alleged logic and name calling and hostility on these boards do sometimes bother me - I like most of these folks, respect them and their opinions and enjoy this game
1/25/2010 1:10 PM
Quote: Originally Posted By metsmax on 1/25/2010

Quote: Originally Posted By colonels19 on 1/25/2010

I'm calling anyone who doesn't think that the sim can/should be different from real life an idiot, because if you don't/can't understand that there are many different factors in each "game" that determine outcomes, what other conclusion can you come to?

The rankings thing is really apples to oranges. WIS uses what RL uses (human polls and RPI/SOS) and if used/applied properly, it would work just fine. There's no doubt in my mind that if my RL rankings were used here, that you would see the same quality here as you do in my RL rankings because nothing will have changed in the implementation.

and who specifically said he "doesn't think that the sim can/should be different from real life" The way that he mocked me that I would use that as an excuse, suggests that he believes otherwise, thus I jumped on the RL/sim comparison. If he sees how they can/should be different, he should speak up.

now please be specific because you are calling folks idiots and putting words in their mouths.....an odd combination if you think about it

and to be 100% clear, colonel - I have no problem with you personally, but your fast a loose use of words and alleged logic because you don't agree with me doesn't mean that what I do isn't logical...i.e. all wins rate higher than all losses.and name calling this is rather rare and almost a joke now. and hostility on these boards do sometimes bother me - I like most of these folks, respect them and their opinions and enjoy this game - and I dont enjoy people who try so hard as you to offend and irritate Part of the thing is here, is that you guys think that you're going to keep digging at me here and making references to what you may consider my bizarre claims and you expect me to keep quiet? Its frankly not going to happen. You guys want to jab, I'll jab back. You guys want to be civil, I'll be civil, but I'm not just going to "take my licks" silently, just because I'm unpopular here. If we're playing some kind of game here on the boards, I will not lose, period.

1/25/2010 1:17 PM
so lets study the specific reply

I asked:

and who specifically said he "doesn't think that the sim can/should be different from real life"

the colonel answers:

The way that he mocked me that I would use that as an excuse, suggests that he believes otherwise, thus I jumped on the RL/sim comparison. If he sees how they can/should be different, he should speak up.

So, folks get called "idiots" based on what the colonel thinks mockery suggests they may think - without regard to whether they said or even implied the position which the colonel attributes to them

AND THEN, the colonel fulminates about how folks are against him and in the same message - amazingly - says that name calling is rare

hypocrisy and sophistry - you are just making stuff up and have no defense for your name calling and the words you put into the mouths of others
1/25/2010 1:32 PM
can you do better?

remember, you called him an idiot....but your name calling is rare....I know you said that.....and you said that he took a position....but he didnt.....and you said that you have logic.....but I'm looking for it....

and you said that folks want you to stop posting because.....hmmm you didnt have a reason....I am troubled by hypocrites and sophists
1/25/2010 1:35 PM
Quote: Originally Posted By metsmax on 1/25/2010
so lets study the specific reply

I asked:

and who specifically said he "doesn't think that the sim can/should be different from real life"

the colonel answers:

The way that he mocked me that I would use that as an excuse, suggests that he believes otherwise, thus I jumped on the RL/sim comparison. If he sees how they can/should be different, he should speak up.

So, folks get called "idiots" based on what the colonel thinks mockery suggests they may think - without regard to whether they said or even implied the position which the colonel attributes to them

AND THEN, the colonel fulminates about how folks are against him and in the same message - amazingly - says that name calling is rare

hypocrisy and sophistry - you are just making stuff up and have no defense for your name calling and the words you put into the mouths of others
suggests that he believes otherwise, thus I jumped on the RL/sim comparison

It suggested it to colonels mind, therefore it statistically has to be true.
1/25/2010 1:35 PM
Quote: Originally Posted By metsmax on 1/25/2010
so lets study the specific reply

I asked:

and who specifically said he "doesn't think that the sim can/should be different from real life"

the colonel answers:

The way that he mocked me that I would use that as an excuse, suggests that he believes otherwise, thus I jumped on the RL/sim comparison. If he sees how they can/should be different, he should speak up.

So, folks get called "idiots" based on what the colonel thinks mockery suggests they may think - without regard to whether they said or even implied the position which the colonel attributes to them

AND THEN, the colonel fulminates about how folks are against him and in the same message - amazingly - says that name calling is rare

hypocrisy and sophistry - you are just making stuff up and have no defense for your name calling and the words you put into the mouths of others
Let's look at my initial response to aintheb, shall we?

"For the 7000th time, if you can't see how the sim can/should be different than real life, then I'm quite simply wasting my time with an idiot."

I'm saying IF HE DOESN'T see this, then I'd be wasting my time with an idiot....I'm not necessarily calling him an idiot, its all dependent on his response back to see if he sees that the 2 should be different or not. Anyone who thinks this is an idiot to me and there's no reason to debate with someone that thinks the the sim and RL should operate the same way and that RL should somehow be the barometer/justification stick for everything that happens.

The name calling has become a bit of a joke now, I use the term boob very loosely...did it earlier in a thread somewhere to participate in the banter. If people are upset that I choose to sometimes use their first names, tough...you can use mine all you want, you know where it is and guess what, I'm not offended if you call me Trevor *GASP*!
1/25/2010 1:40 PM
edit: TREVOR- i think i know the problem. you come in here and you get in long arguments like on this thread. people dont respect you- that is a fact. the reason people dont respect you is because you have had no success in HD. your lack of success makes it hard for me to value your opinions on things like the game engine. if you went out and showed you could make some sweet 16s and then some final fours that would impress me and show me along with the other users you knew what you were doing. i feel like im rambling but i think you get the point: win some games.
1/25/2010 1:49 PM
right, so you exaggerate someone else's point of view, put foolish words into his mouth and then call him and idiot....or boob....loosely speaking.....

and Phillip, although I think that some of what you say makes a sense - see for example the minutes complaint thread - this sort of argument fritters away your credibility
1/25/2010 1:51 PM
◂ Prev 1...3|4|5|6|7 Next ▸
33 Points in 1 OT Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.