Update from 38 months ago:
Futility:
322 seasons.
6,386 wins.
sweet sixteen - 18 (42 total)
elite eight - 13 (24 total)
final four - 8 (11 total)
natl final - 3 (3 total, all Div 1)
champs - 0 (0 total)
Oof. That i couldn't have just lucked into one ring via my 24 Elite Eights or my 11 Final Fours is unbelievable, lol.

I have 2 current D-3 contenders in the top-ten (update, St Olaf made F4 in Season 202), but i just assume i'll get bounced at some point, like a pebble falling thru one of those filtering screens... either via sucking at line or whatever the F.

Still very much new to this game, but let’s see what my tally is.

49 seasons
998 wins
26 conference championships
Nat final - 0
final four - 4
elite eight - 3
sweet sixteen - 9
round two - 9
first round - 6

31 appearances. So not a ton but getting up there. The 4 F4’s are a heartbreak. Seems like I get stuck at the S16 a lot.

Because I’m curious how my stats compare:
77 seasons
1345 wins
29 conference championships
2 NT Championships (one of which felt extremely lucky)
Final Four- 0
Elite Eight- 1
Sweet Sixteen- 7
Second Round- 15
First Round- 15
Total appearances- 40

One of my championship teams had 6 seniors. If you’re looking for a strategy to break through and win a championship in the lower divisions, 6 seniors is a good way to go. However, of course, the following season is a rebuild. My current goal is to produce teams that at least make the Sweet 16 consistently every season.