Posted by trobone on 7/15/2013 12:10:00 PM (view original):
WIS is the best i've ever found.
OOTP baseball is detailed to the point where I can't get into it.
Hattrick is fun - but not quite detailed or fast enough. your team players 1-2 games a week.
HD is my favorite game on WIS, followed by HBD and GD.
100% agree with this.
OOTP is just a little too much work to have as much replay value as HD.
Hattrick is way too slow.
GD is too much work to maintain that roster size, HD is just perfect in that regard. HBD is definitely growing on me too.
One you didn't mention that I used to enjoy is Imagine Sports..very similar to WIS's sim league baseball, but better imo. I still prefer HD, though.