If you're team is playing in the D-3 championship, which scoring guard would  you select and why? All other factors not listed are even. Which offense would you run? You won't go wrong with any of these guys and the skill level is fairly close, but I'm interested in people's opinion on which skills do you value the most on offense.

A) 50Ath 85Spd 90PE 20LP85BH OffIQ A- FT C
B) 55Ath 80Spd 85PE 20LP 95BH OffIQ B+ FT C
C) 40Ath 95Spd 85PE 20LP 90BH  OffIQ C FT C
D) 60Ath 75Spd 80PE 20LP80BH OffIQ A+ FT C
E) 50Ath 70Spd 95PE 20LP 90BH OffIQ A FT C

What level?

E

Posted by Trentonjoe on 2/13/2014 3:47:00 PM (view original):
What level?

D-3

A. Guys like that are virtually uncoverable. That type of shooter is going t o rely on spd and per.

Posted by Trentonjoe on 2/13/2014 4:23:00 PM (view original):
A. Guys like that are virtually uncoverable. That type of shooter is going t o rely on spd and per.

True, however I wonder Player A's ability to finish near the basket with his lower athleticism, especially one with excellent ball handling skills and speed.

I'll take the lower athleticism guy and lower IQ guy and go with C. I like the spd+pe+bh factors.

I know they're equal, but where do they stand at FT%? Equal at 50% and equal at 90% can be very different things.

Posted by zbrent716 on 2/13/2014 5:06:00 PM (view original):
I know they're equal, but where do they stand at FT%? Equal at 50% and equal at 90% can be very different things.

That's true. For argument's sake, I gave each player a C. Forgot about free throws.

At C FT, I'm close between A and E, but I'll go E. Probably around B-/B FT, and I move towards A.