This is in regards to DII recruits.

I'm leaning towards A, but player B is going to have elite speed and potentially elite shooting and LP (starting in the mid 50's with H-H potential). Will the high speed and better scoring ability be good enough to offset the lower ath. The lower bh and pass also further contributes to my lean towards A.

Player A: projection - Ath 60+, Spd 72, Def 51, Per 60+, BH 70, pass, 70
Player B: projection - Ath 25, Spd 90+, Def 45, LP 75+, Per 75+, BH 55, pass 50.

Definitely A.

I'd use B as a feature second unit scorer - His Ath/Def as a little suspect to start for me.

What do you need? If you need a pg choose A. If you need a scorer choose B.

I think player B is more common and easier to recruit. Player A is harder to find, I would probably choose him in a vacuum.

Just realized that i didnt really answer the right question... but player A is still my final answer.

thanks guys. I was figuring A too, but the thought of the elite scorer that wasn't far off defensively from the other guy was tempting.