I see Farrier as your best scorer. I love that ATH/SPD/BH/FT at D3. He'd get shots at D2. Rogers looks like he should be competing with Zamorano to be your #2 - Rogers is similar to Farrier, but not quite as good.
In M2M you're probably right that Pearce's defense makes him a backup, but I really like him as a bench scorer at -1 or even 0.