A new take on another thread...

For the purpose of this discussion, let's presume that all of these players will be seen "in their prime"


C:  Josh Gibson
1B:  Jimmie Foxx (I would have put Mark McGwire but I did see him several times - I can't imagine anyone putting on a better show)
2B:  Rogers Hornsby
SS:  Honus Wagner
3B:  John McGraw
OF:  James "Cool Papa" Bell
OF:  Ty Cobb
OF:  The Babe

SP:  Satchel Paige / Walter Johnson / Christy Mathewson / Rube Waddell / Sandy Koufax
RP:  Goose Gossage

thats a good one...not much room to improve upon.....maybe Pie Trainer at third base.....Addie Joss instead of Waddell.

Since yours covered the greats so well.....

c:  Munson....only seen highlights against the Bosox...would have been neat to see live against Boston
1b:  Sunny Jim Bottomley, you already took Foxx, and for some reason, I like the guy
2b:  Nap Lajoie......race for the batting title vs Cobb, from New England
ss:  Joe Cronin, no exciting reason....
3b:  Brooks Robinson
of:  mantle, mays, Ted WIlliams....only seen the stats and the stories

sp:  Old Hoss Radboure, - pitched almost everyday in 1884.......Lefty Grove, got ****** at Cronin's error's at SS ....Luis Tiant, only seen highlights and stories
rp:  Dick Radatz....apparently, pretty intimidating.

Mine would just be Tigers legends.
Mickey Cochrane, Charlie Gehringer, Alan Trammel, Ty Cobb, Hank Greenberg. Heck, I wish I could've seen Miguel Cabrera cuz ESPN will only play Yanks-Red Sox even if they're fighting for last place. If not them then it's the Cardinals. I only got to see the Tigers when they played the ChiSox when they owned that one TV Network