Oh absolutely, if you search the stats across levels there are always a handful every year, but the majority of them seem to be SIMs.
couple of examples in Rupp (22 games in)
D2 center, 53 ATH, 98 REB, A in the Zone
D2 center, 36 !!! ATH, 97 REB, A- in the Zone
D3 center, 5 !!! ATH, 89 REB, A- in the zone
D3 center, 48 ATH, 94 REB, A- in M2M
Granted, all sims, all playing decent minutes (>25), but there's some sucky ratings there. You'd think well recruited guys with proper cores for this would be more successful.