Comparing, the other team is 4-4 against the top 100 rpi, 1-3 against the top 50 RPI, 0-1 against the top 25 RPI - no embarrassing losses.
You are 4-11 against top 100, 1-9 against top 50 and 0-7 against the top 25. Also no embarrassing losses.
Loook at those teams with the numbers filed off, which resume is superior.