First of all, Hawking doesn't represent a consensus, even if he has fully changed his mind. Second, I don't know that he's ever suggested that matter is not irreversibly annihilated in a black hole, only that radiation can escape. Although I do think most reliable pictures of black holes at this point do agree that entry into a black hole is a theoretically reversible process, IE the information is retained on some fundamental level. But that doesn't make it recognizable.