Which one of these guys has a bigger impact on overall offense as a PG? Flex Offese, D3, IQ is essentially the same,

Name	Yr.	Pos.	A	SPD	REB					BH	P		ST		FT
Ruben Gr	Jr.	PG	50	92	16					60	73		83		C+
Johnathon Pickrell	Jr.	PG	50	80	8					87	61		72		B

why leave out PER?

1. I left out all the scoring stats because I don't think they are relevant. I know how I am going to set their distro. I am really just looking for who will have a bigger impact on the teams offense.

2. Also, I am pretty confident #1 is better, my real question is how much better? There is a large gap in the defensive rating and scoring ability. Is it worth moving them around or is #1's impact on team offense that much more.

If I remember your theory Trenton : It would be 1. But i'd start Pickrell against press. It's pretty close but I always like passing... I think it's probably the most important stat on a pg.

Gragg. But not by much.

I like the first guy better, but not a whole lot better.

1. I don't think either player has been to the free throw line that many times to make that much of an impact/difference, so the difference between the B and C+ free throw grade is very very minimal.

2. The fact that you run a press has me liking the high stamina guy. 83-70

3. Athleticism is the same. 12 point speed difference definitely helps.

4. Against the press, I would "consider" the second guy(BH+P) over the first guy. Against all other defenses, I would go with the first guy.

5. Guards rebounding, not that much of a difference to matter.

6. Also take into consideration that speed=steals which also translates into transition points, so there is an indirect relationship from defense to offense.

If I had to pick, I would go with player 1 because of the speed advantage and he's going to be more effective with the higher stamina rating.