Shows will be a good D3 scorer as a shooting guard. I'd set him at -2 (maybe -1 sometimes, depending on matchups) and about 40% of your starting 5 distribution. Yelle is an acceptable D3 low-distro PG, though will be better with better IQ as the year goes on. Damato is probably your best 2nd option, around 25% of the starting 5. I probably would not go the full Dickinson route here, though Shows is a great guy to lean on in flex. You'll be living and dying with the mid-range jump shot, which is a tough way to play, but it can be done.