I think Northern Colorado was an advantage for me when I got here, 20+ seasons ago in Naismith. I didn't have much D2 human competition in CO (or nearby states), and in D1, Univ of Colorado was always going to be going after much higher-level talent, so our paths never crossed. I think that's the key to look for - a combo of reasonable D1 talent within 300-500 miles, plus D1 schools that are going to consistently aim higher than you.
Now, I've got 3 other A or A+ D2 schools in CO, and I'm fading on the recruiting trail. Oh well, things change.