Best team to coach? Topic

I’m wondering what the consensus is on what team is the best to coach in D1 when factoring in baseline prestige, conference prestige, location, local recruiting, etc?

i figure it’s one of the blue bloods/A+ prestige schools, but I’d love to hear everyone’s opinion.
8/5/2019 12:06 AM
UCLA
8/5/2019 4:19 AM
UCLA, UConn, Kansas, Duke, UNC, Kentucky.......seems to me that all these teams are roughly equal across the worlds I have been in. It seems that with a good coach, UCLA and UConn stand out as the giving the best opportunity for maintaining success. I think UConn's baseline A+ must be through the roof.
8/5/2019 8:28 AM
Posted by snafu4u on 8/5/2019 8:28:00 AM (view original):
UCLA, UConn, Kansas, Duke, UNC, Kentucky.......seems to me that all these teams are roughly equal across the worlds I have been in. It seems that with a good coach, UCLA and UConn stand out as the giving the best opportunity for maintaining success. I think UConn's baseline A+ must be through the roof.
Kentucky's location is waay worse than UCLA. It's not even close.

UCLA is by far the best.
8/5/2019 8:42 AM
Yeah I’ve got a solid run going at LSU but that baseline prestige would be nice. Kansas was open but I could not bring myself to jump on it.

What about Syracuse, Illinois, or Michigan St?
8/5/2019 1:34 PM
I'm not a D1 guy, but all the schools your mentioning could all be grouped together "somewhat". The reason UCLA stands alone is because places like California and NY have the most elite recruits generated. But at UCLA, you have no threats around you. No elite threats. You may have built up mid majors and things like that.

Syracuse has UConn, Duke has UNC and vice versa. Illinois and Michigan St are grouped together similarly. UCLA is on a planet by itself in comparison.
8/5/2019 2:27 PM
My off the cuff list of best d1 jobs for all A schools.

UCLA
Cuse
UConn
Kansas
Zona
Duke/unc (whoever you hate less)
Illinois
Wisconsin
MSU
Stanford
UK
BC
OU
Florida
Maryland
Cincy
Louisville
GT
NC state or Wake
Indiana

Best non A baseline jobs - Texas, Colorado and Minnesota
8/5/2019 4:21 PM (edited)
LSU has to be on that list.
8/5/2019 4:50 PM
i agree that UK is nothing like UCLA. when i've coached UK, you are surrounded on all sides, and there are typically a lot of b+/a- type school in the area that make things more complicated.

in 2.0 i think it was more pronounced - that 200 mile radius was just so overwhelmingly important, and the 360. in 3.0, i think you have a bit more tolerance built into the system. still, i definitely feel like each area has its own flavor, and its not really set world over world. each world has its own best school / area that changes over time.

also, baseline prestige is overrated. one of the best jobs i ever had was texas a&m (b-? b?) with weak texas schools. LSU and oklahoma schools overlap in the market, but if you can hit a texas a&m type school with like an a- at texas or baylor and a b+ at lsu and just 1 a+ from the OK schools, you could really haul it in. i feel like LSU is in the same boat, that southern SEC area can be *really* weak when you get the right arrangement of coaches. in one world we would reach down regularly into that area, i think from michigan state it was, or maybe ohio state. just depends who happens to be there - have an a+ lsu with a couple a/a+ texas schools, and a few good (b+/a- ish) schools in that auburn/bama/vandy/tn/georgia range, along with a strong ga tech (which is a very solid school on average and frequently is staffed by a strong coach), and its a different story. but there is potential for some dominance.

it also used to matter way more in 2.0 because of conference battling - being on the outskirts of the conference was way better. so MSU had a major advantage because none of the local schools would even battle you (although, you couldn't really exactly battle them, either - but this matters less when you are the big dog). i really like that conference battling is a thing now, that was super messed up in 2.0.

anyway, other than the A+ schools mentioned above, i think the following have some really good potential -
- texas schools and lsu (not tech, although that matters less now - tech is straight garbage in 2.0, one of the worst big 6 up there with hawaii)
- miami fl (used to have huge advantage on PR players, and on miami players over florida - may be less attractive now)
- ga tech
- colorado (i won a title on C recruited players once, at colorado - if you get a weaker MWC, you can absolutely clean up)

i thought a++ prestige still existed based on some early data from my time back (which i guess i'm a little over 2 months now). but now not so sure. i do question whether an a++++ school can just destroy the world now, with the way that once you cap out a player, that's it. so that may make a+ baseline more useful than it used to be, at least at the really high end of d1 play, which is sort of the question here i guess.
8/5/2019 6:27 PM
Best team to coach? Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.