Drafted Frankie Frisch in a draft league. Will play him at 2b. Limited to years 1921 to 1923 for theme reasons. Should I go with 21 Frisch (better fielding, not as good offense) or 21 Frisch?

What is the rest of your team like? Do you have a ton of offense already? What is the salary cap in the league? What is your pitching staff like? Do you need good infield defense?

It is hard to answer your question or even to give useful advice without more information and context.

Offense:

BB	AB/HR	AVG	OBP	SLG	F/R	Salary
		C	1922 Johnny Bassler	L	477	392	0	41	2-1	12-62	372.0	.323	.422	.360	C+/C	$4,136,428
		1B	click to draft
		2B	1923 Frankie Frisch	S	744	679	12	111	29-12	12-46	53.4	.348	.395	.485	B/B	$7,918,856
		3B	1921 Aaron Ward	R	673	589	5	75	6-8	68-42	111.2	.306	.363	.423	C/B-	$6,166,684
		SS	1921 Everett Scott	R	653	606	1	62	5-9	21-27	576.0	.262	.295	.335	A/A-	$4,641,200
		OF	1922 Zack Wheat	L	695	632	16	112	9-6	22-45	37.5	.335	.388	.503	A/C-	$5,912,042
		OF	1921 Walton Cruise	L	427	365	8	55	10-8	24-48	43.0	.346	.429	.503	C/B-	$4,014,181
		OF	1921 Irish Meusel	R	662	617	14	87	13-13	29-33	41.9	.343	.380	.515	D/C	$5,109,033

Pitching

S	IP/162	ERA	OAV	WHIP	K/9	BB/9	HR/9	K-BB	Salary
		SP	1923 Herb Pennock	L	19-6-3	255	3.13	.261	1.27	3.51	2.57	0.42	93-68	$6,208,104
		SP/RP	1921 Sam Jones	R	23-16-1	315	3.22	.279	1.33	2.95	2.35	0.03	98-78	$9,787,632
		SP/RP	1923 Howard Ehmke	R	20-17-3	338	3.78	.272	1.38	3.44	3.38	0.34	121-119	$7,506,987
		SP/RP	1923 Rube Benton	L	14-10-1	231	3.66	.284	1.37	2.42	2.34	0.41	59-57	$5,336,142
		SP/RP	click to draft
		SP/RP	1922 Claude Jonnard	R	6-1-5	101	3.84	.272	1.29	4.13	2.63	0.66	44-28	$2,077,259

Will be playing in Yankee Stadium I, so a defensive stadium

Obviously I am not done drafting yet, but have the full lineup except 1b. Probably 1b will not end up being an impact player as we are far into the draft already

I think i have an offensively focused team, but it is such an offensive era in the early 20s maybe i am wrong

I would take the 1921 version, the difference on offense is minimal and you get a substantial fielding upgrade plus much better speed. The 1921 Frisch is underpriced due to having a great glove at a secondary position.

edit: Just saw your pitching staff, you will get a ton out of an A+ fielder with how many hits that staff is gonna give up.

Thanks

Yes 21, that A+ range and speed is huge.

'21 for sure.

Consensus is 21. Going with 21. Appreciate the advice.