Signing Tendency D-1 Phelan Topic

Thought it would be useful to start a thread, based on the number of signings per cycle and exactly which cycle they signed on . This is just for D-1 Phelan.

12/30 5pm cycle SIGNED(16)(13 early)(3 by end of 1st)(0 whenever)

12/30 11pm cycle SIGNED(39)(18 early)(16 by end of 1st)(5 whenever)

12/31 5am cycle SIGNED(44)(15 early)(18 by end of 1st)(11 whenever)

12/31 11am cycle SIGNED (35)(13 early)(11 by end of 1st)(11 whenever)

12/31 5pm cycle SIGNED(44)(10 early)(21 by end of 1st)(13 whenever)

12/31 11pm cycle SIGNED(32)(5 early)(12 by end of 1st)(15(whenever)

1/1 5am cycle SIGNED(20)(4 early)(8 by end of 1st)(8 whenever)

1/1/ 11am cycle SIGNED(11)(5 early)(3 by end of 1st)(3 whenever)

Total SIGNED (241)(83 early)(92 end of 1st)(66 whenever)
1/1/2018 3:01 PM (edited)
Interesting to note so far:

0 "whenever's" signed on the 1st cycle.

After the 2nd cycle, there are almost as many "end of 1st" and there are "early's". Could "end of 1st" mean they won't sign on the 1st cycle?
12/31/2017 12:16 AM
updated through 5pm.

Notes
*Number of recruits that signed "early" and "end of the 1st" are even 24 hours after signings started.
*Only 16 signed on the 1st cycle, but became more consistent after that, right about 40 signings for each cycle.
*It will be interesting to see if there ends up being close to the same amount of "early's""end of 1st" and "whenever's". at the end of recruiting.
12/31/2017 7:31 PM (edited)
This is great. Please update it through the end of recruiting in Phelan.
1/1/2018 2:30 PM
I remember seeing explanations of what the various tendencies mean– i.e. the stipulations/ probabilities to sign in the early period for each of the classifications. Can somebody please help me find that information? I would be very grateful
8/23/2020 6:21 AM
I did a bit of a list in early v3. Analyzing about 5000 D1 recruits.
This only includes recruits that were considering a D1 school for each signing period.

Early tendency is as you'd expect. 18% in the first 5pm cycle of signings. 46% by the 11pm. 72% by 5am, 88% by 11am, 94% by the second 5pm period.

End-1: 4% first 5pm period. 19% by 11pm, 35% by 5am, 55% by 11am, 77% by second 5pm. 91% by 11pm.

Whenever is as expected covers the gamut: 1 of 504 that were considering a D1 team signed during the first 5pm cycle. 12% by 11pm. 30% by 5am. 45% by 11am, 63% by 5pm second day 79% by 11pm. Only about 9% held out for the Late recruiting session.
8/23/2020 2:18 PM
And when you say “considering,” that’s independent of whether the interest is high or very high, O.W.?
8/23/2020 11:32 PM
Lil' Wizzy is still around?!

Come on back to Phelan so the A10 can smack ya around some more.
8/24/2020 11:37 AM
Posted by ab90 on 8/23/2020 11:32:00 PM (view original):
And when you say “considering,” that’s independent of whether the interest is high or very high, O.W.?
Yep. At least one D1 team was at high or better at the time of the signing.

So it's often a fluid number from cycle to cycle as more and more recruits are targeted later in recruiting.
8/24/2020 5:44 PM
So do those with "late" signing preference always wait until the second recruiting session to sign?

Does anyone know when they start signing during the second recruiting session?
9/8/2020 5:16 PM
Yes they ALWAYS wait until RS2. No exceptions.

and they can begin signing at any point. Sometimes it can be the very first cycle of RS2. Sometimes it can be the last. But the closer it gets towards the end of RS2, the chances get higher each cycle that he will sign.
9/9/2020 3:56 AM
Signing Tendency D-1 Phelan Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.