Player A: OF rating B/D+ (.985/1.95) 1990s
Player B: 1B rating D/D (.974/.904) 1920s

1 of those guys has to start at 1B. The other starts at DH.

I have used similar OFers at 1B before, such as Manny Ramirez, Tony Gwynn, & Bonds...

I have used Edgar Martinez & Frank Thomas at 1B before

I don't think there will be much of a difference tbh...

What do you think?

Raw translation with monkey math has your OF at a .970 FLD% at 1B, so the other guy should be slightly better defensively, especially if there’s more modern pitching, but it’s close to a wash.

Yeah, I think your OF is going to be about a D/D- (on the high end of both) so it doesn't really matter. But remember that you can play DHs down to a lower fatigue level (since you're not hurting their fielding), in case that matters

What's on second.............

Yeah. I realized that I actually have a D/D 1B starting in another league right now and he has 4 errors and 4 negative plays in 87 games... I can live with that. I'm going to start the 1B at 1B.
Thanks for the input

I dont know....................third base.

Is it possible that there are people here young enough to not get the "Who's On First?" reference?

Just in case:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sShMA85pv8M

Just found this "sequel":

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K0Jg7pvVzKk