I think it is very contingent upon the area you are in and the surrounding human coaches. They are fairly similar but I definitely see some more upside in the second player, but think the first is still a very solid D3 player, especially with the Ath/LP combination. If the second guy gets strong growth out of his LP, he could be a better scorer with that high BH.
I would get a feeling out of how the first couple cycles pan out and adjust accordingly. Again, happy to have either player on my d3 squad but do think the second guy is a bit better.
I may also add that if you are running press, the second player may struggle to stay on the floor with the really low stamina. Going to take him a couple years to get to a comfortable level. I would let that weigh heavily on your mind if that is the defensive set you are running.