I'd say the talent you bring in depends on a lot of factors but yes, it is 100% important to at least try? I'd love if you were near me just punting an RS2.
At D1, I will commonly target international recruits when I get to the new job since I can full send them with resources. I've pulled in some really talented players. You can also target a local guy if that is preferred.
At D2, I just pulled in 2 studs during my RS2 with W.Florida in Smith, should 100% be starters in the NT all 4 years. One international uncontested, one local guy being protected by a D1. At NW Naz in Iba, I pulled in a dominant big and a strong SF.
So yeah, I'd say just punting RS2 is a pretty horrible idea.