i think 2 would grab more boards, overall.
i never really gave it that much thought, but sweetdude is prolly right about off and def boards.
I tend to think player 1 would be a better overall player.
Are we talking about recruiting?
like...who would i take?
if so, hmmm.
It really depends on thier potential. most likely i like #1 unless his RE is lowPot. or if #1 has hiPot in ath/sp