I've always had my own opinion on this, but I think I've finally realized that my opinion is probably wrong. What is the most important rating to determine how good a scorer a guard will be? Is it PER, SPD, ATH or BH? The reason I ask is that I have the three guards below on one of my teams and don't know which should be the best scorer. Any thoughts would be appreciated.

#1 (PG): ATH-100, SPD-89, PER-46, BH-99

#2 (PG): ATH-45, SPD-96, PER-74, BH-96

#3 (SG): ATH-76, SPD-90, PER-81, BH-92

3

3 for sure.

IMO, the order for guards is speed/ath/bh/per for scoring. Obviously #3 is your best scorer. #1 would likely be the best true PG. #2 would be your best hybird pg/sg player.

agree, #1 is the best PG

I was looking at your team and realized the two PGs are both from the same HS.

Quote: Originally Posted By tkimble on 2/01/2010I was looking at your team and realized the two PGs are both from the same HS

Wow. You know my team better than I do. I didn't realize that until you mentioned it. Of all the high schools in all the states... what are the odds?

Anyhow, thanks for the input guys.

3 will be far and away the best scorer

Quote: Originally posted by tkimble on 2/01/2010I was looking at your team and realized the two PGs are both from the same HS.

That would have been a fun H.S. team to coach.

Ok, FUrry, what would your order be for SF's?

Ath/reb/speed/lp/pe/bh/def/passing/sb in that order.


Ath/reb/lp/speed/sb/pass/def/bh/per for my bigs.