I guess I like the "Free Range" as oposed to a Draft... lot of players out there, probably won't be too many, maybe no duplicates. But if the goal is to have no duplucates maybe a draft is in order. Same player is OK- just has to be a different team version of that player. Random in that case. But I'm completely on the fence and equitable to any decision made, lol.
Just no Obstructionists or Philabusters, please :-))