Just trying to get a consensus. All else being equal, which point guard would you choose?

A SPD PER BH PA

pg A 30 60 50 50 50

pg B 30 60 35 60 60

They aren't different enough for me to make a judgement. I would probably chose A though, because balanced players seem to perform better.

For me it would depend on how good my perimeter shooting is at the starting SG and SF positions. If I had good PER numbers on the SG and SF, I would prefer to have Option B the better distributor on the floor with them as there are only so many shots to go around. Now if I only had one (or none) good PER players starting at SG and SF then I would play Option A as his outside shooting ability would come in handy with keeping my teams shot selection more balanced.

Quote: Originally posted by fatchance on 3/21/2010For me it would depend on how good my perimeter shooting is at the starting SG and SF positions. If I had good PER numbers on the SG and SF, I would prefer to have Option B the better distributor on the floor with them as there are only so many shots to go around. Now if I only had one (or none) good PER players starting at SG and SF then I would play Option A as his outside shooting ability would come in handy with keeping my teams shot selection more balanced.

What he said...