any chance you only checked his list within a couple minutes of the cycle rolling over? meaning, if he signed at 11pm, did you check his list between 8:05 and 10:57? sometimes weird stuff shows up on the dividing lines that makes no sense, thats all i can think of to explain your situation, if you are sure you checked his list i would send a ticket, as that situation is supposed to be impossible. you can wait until after recruiting if you are afraid they will take the player away to "fix" the problem, but i would be very surprised if that happened...