I was wondering if anyone has ever tried to come up with a formula to try to gauge the true effectiveness of the player so that they could be compared to other players. I'm thinking about trying it and am seeking input. If anyone knows anybody who has tried something like this before I'd love a sitemail.

I have done this exact thing in the past, but anymore it is not worth the time IMO. It is a lot easier to just look at a recruit for a minute and compare him to others. Especially since it is all about potential and not ratings in recruiting now a days.

Plus it is very subjective. I put more weight into IQ then most people would. I mean I would be happy to give you an idea of what categories I would value over others but it is really worthless to do without knowing a players potential.

Are you trying to decide which players to start/come off the bench or which players to recruit?