To me, its simple, if you think both HAVE to be on your opening day roster next year, call them up now, as you'll have the same amount of service time towards arbitration if you bring them up now, or if you bring them up next season. If you can live w/o them on your roster for the first 20 minor league games next year, leave them down in the minors for the rest of this year. You said you're not going anywhere this season, so if you can squeeze the 20 games w/o them next year, that's 1 more year you'll have them cheap. Both have room to grow playing the minors, so I don't think you're hurting them by leaving them down there another half season + 20 games.