Irregardless of position and need, which player is the best among these 5?

http://img814.imageshack.us/i/players.jpg/

It's impossible to say this with certainty without knowing what system you run, but all other things being equal, I'd take player #4. He might end up a step slow, but with the high potential in athleticism, low-post, and perimeter, as well as a pretty decent starting point in rebounding, you could probably mold him into a solid 2-3 hybrid.

I'm running Triange/M2M.

Without position and need it's impossible to say.  They all have strengths and they all have weaknesses.  If "(ir)regardless of position and need" means you think your team is solid as-is, I would go after #5.  He's offensively worthless but just good enough at passing and ball handling not to be a liability.  Meanwhile he can become a lockdown defender that you could use as a spot-starter against teams with elite scoring guards.  On the other hand, if his defense is low-high he's really pretty worthless.

Actually, between these 2 PG, who would you take:

I believe #2 is the better player, but the WE is scaring me. 

PG 1: 43 WE

Athleticism	43	Low		Perimeter	41	High
Speed	67	Average		Ball Handling	71	Average
Rebounding	2	High		Passing	33	High
Defense	34	Average		Stamina	60	Average
Shot Blocking	1	Average		Durability	50	High
Low-post	1	High		FT Shooting		High

PG 2: 15WE

Athleticism	54	Average		Perimeter	45	Low
Speed	57	High		Ball Handling	49	High
Rebounding	1	Low		Passing	44	High
Defense	51	Low		Stamina	57	High
Shot Blocking	1	Low		Durability	27	High
Low-post	15	Average		FT Shooting		Low

Anyone care to respond within the next 15min? I want to get my recruiting actions in before this cycle ends since signing starts soon. Thanks.

I'd prolly take pg 1

Out of curiosity, suppose you have a PG with 35/85 ath/spd, and another with 80/60 ath/spd, with all other stats equal, which one would you take? I know spd matters more for PG but would you take a PG with such skewed attributes?

anyone, how would you weigh ath/spd for PGs?

35/85. I just think speed is sexy.

pg2 and sg1 are best