I know this is typically not how to draft but after drafting this team, I am stumped where to play.
It is a pretty good defensive team except for left field where it is a D/D.
As a team they have hit .290, with 357 sb, and 196 homeruns.  With 4 lefthanders in the lineup, I have no idea where I should go, do I go to a neutral ballpark, because I have no idea where to go, or should I rely on a small ballpark based on my homeruns?
5/13/2011 11:55 PM
For starters, I wouldn't put your D/D OF in left field if you can avoid it.  I would put him in RF where he will have fewer opportunities to hurt you defensively.  Did you draft three OF's who you can play wherever you want, or are you in a theme league where you have to specifically draft a LF, CF and RF?

5/14/2011 1:20 AM
no, I can place them any where I want, I thought I would put my weakest of in LF you think Rf, ok.
5/14/2011 9:09 AM
The best thing to do is actually look at your opponents' teams and decide where to play him.  The sim treats all hitters as pull hitters, particularly to the outfield.  So if your opponent has more lefties than righties in his lineup, play the guy in left.  If he has more righties, play him in right.

Trying to figure out what your offense is like from numbers without knowing normalization of the players is pretty tough.  196 homeruns in a lineup of all guys from the steroid era is not really going to net you a whole lot in an OL; 196 homers from a lineup of all guys from the '20s will offer a lot more power.  How many CS are there to go along with those steals?  How does  the average normalize?  How much do your guys walk?  Etc.
5/14/2011 8:28 PM
The lineup is a mixture of guys from the 60's to 2001.  It is a theme league of 100million.  they got cs 94 times.  They walked 889 times and struck out 778.  They have a obp of .400. I knnow numbers may not tell the whole story,   I thought the braintrust of the sims could get me a ballpark idea where to play.
5/14/2011 10:42 PM

frank1 -- flattery will get you almost anywhere.  Why don't you post your lineup (pitching rotation, too) and we can give you more informed advice?  As dahsdebater said, it's hard to view your numbers as an abstraction and offer good advice.  Most of us are familiar with the strengths and weaknesses of most of the players in the SIM, who normalizes well, who doesn't, etc. and seeing the actual lineup will help.

 

5/15/2011 12:24 AM
C 1992 Darren Daulton L 585 485 27 109 11-2 103-88 18.0 .270 .385 .524 C+/A- $5,727,850
1B 1999 Jeff Bagwell R 729 562 42 126 30-11 127-149 13.4 .304 .454 .591 B+/C- $7,253,123
2B 1972 Joe Morgan L 716 581 16 73 58-17 44-115 34.5 .292 .417 .435 A/A- $7,887,967
3B 1989 Carney Lansford R 616 551 2 52 37-15 25-51 275.5 .336 .398 .405 B/D- $4,450,243
SS 2000 Alex Rodriguez R 672 554 41 132 15-4 121-100 13.5 .316 .420 .606 A/B $8,267,616
OF 1971 Lou Brock L 720 640 7 61 64-19 107-76 91.4 .313 .385 .425 D/D- $5,056,519
OF 1989 Rickey Henderson R 674 541 12 57 77-14 68-126 45.1 .274 .411 .399 B+/B- $5,639,426
OF 1997 Barry Bonds L 690 532 40 101 37-8 87-145 13.3 .291 .446 .585 B/C- $6,989,909
2B 1971 Julian Javier R 276 259 3 28 5-1 33-9 86.3 .259 .286 .347 C+/D- $1,262,136
OF 1992 Stan Javier S 66 58 1 5 1-2 11-6 58.0 .190 .277 .293 B/C+ $358,494
C 1961 Tim McCarver L 72 71 1 6 0-0 5-0 67.0 .239 .239 .343 D/C $256,922
2B 1965 Dal Maxvill R 99 90 0 10 0-0 15-7 89.0 .135 .206 .202 A/D- $207,284
OF 1969 Jim Hicks R 110 92 4 11 0-1 32-17 23.0 .130 .264 .304 A+/D- $344,681
    Util  optional                          
    Util  optional                          
    Util  optional                          
    Util  optional                          
    Util  optional                          
    Util  optional                          
Batting Totals 6025 5016 196 771 335-94 778-889 25.4 .290 .400 .474 B/C $53,702,170
Pitching Staff
    Role Player T W-L-S IP/
162
ERA OAV WHIP K/
9
BB/
9
HR/
9
K-BB Salary
SP 1964 Bob Gibson R 19-12-1 288 3.01 .232 1.17 7.67 2.69 0.78 245-86 $7,366,543
SP/RP 1962 Bobby Shantz L 6-4-4 79 1.95 .211 1.09 7.01 2.87 0.92 61-25 $2,171,221
SP/RP 1990 Dave Stewart R 22-11-0 267 2.56 .231 1.16 5.60 2.80 0.54 166-83 $7,391,132
SP/RP 1992 Curt Schilling R 14-11-2 227 2.35 .201 0.99 5.85 2.35 0.44 147-59 $7,791,874
SP/RP 1993 Doug Linton R 2-0-0 26 7.71 .324 1.91 6.66 4.91 2.81 19-14 $200,000
SP/RP 1969 Steve Carlton L 17-11-0 237 2.17 .216 1.18 8.00 3.54 0.57 210-93 $7,092,315
SP/RP 1972 Tom Hall L 10-1-8 131 2.61 .173 1.07 9.70 4.05 0.94 134-56 $4,071,677
SP/RP 1990 Gene Nelson R 3-3-5 75 1.57 .208 0.96 4.58 2.05 0.60 38-17 $2,349,869
SP/RP 1963 Ray Washburn R 5-3-0 65 3.08 .212 0.99 6.58 1.96 0.70 47-14 $1,756,472
SP/RP 1999 Jose Cabrera R 4-0-0 30 2.15 .198 1.02 8.59 2.76 0.92 28-9 $936,312
SP/RP 1988 Dennis Eckersley R 4-2-45 73 2.35 .198 0.87 8.67 1.36 0.62 70-11 $2,813,922
SP/RP 1966 Joe Hoerner L 5-1-13 76 1.54 .212 1.03 7.46 2.49 0.59 63-21 $2,306,890
    SP/RP  optional                      
Pitching Totals
5/15/2011 1:17 AM

A few quick thoughts.  This is a pretty good team for someone getting started, and I would keep the nucleus.  You've drafted more innings than you will need in any ballpark (ignore SIM's advice).  You've got about 1500.  You only need 1200-1250 in ballparks with a singles factor of 0, less in ballparks with negative singles factors and only 1300 or so in even the most offense-oriented parks like Coors and Atlanta Fulton County.  Boogerlips has a nice analysis of innings needed for various types of parks in a recent thread .  I'll try to bump it up, although I think it's intended for $80 MM leagues, not $100 MM.

Your pitchers also give up too many HR's.  You'll be surprised at the extent to which guys like Gibson, Shantz, Carlton and Hall get rocked.   I try to keep pitcher's ERC# under about 2.30 and HR/9 under 0.50 (way under 0.50) except for mops and special circumstances.  SIM has a lot more bashers than these guys faced in an average game in RL.  I would convert some of the long relievers with 75-100+ IP to guys with under 50 IP and low ERC# and low HR/9.

On the offensive side of the ledger, Joe Morgan and A-Rod may disappoint.  They don't normalize terribly well and A-Rod in particular will get fewer HR's than you expect.  Bonds and Bagwell should do well.  If you have AAA players, I would get rid of all the scrubs for whom you paid over $200K.  The AAA will perform better than the scrubs.  You should definitely get rid of Julian Javier.  You don't need his PA's at 2B, and he doesn't bring anything to the table either offensively or defensively.

Because your pitchers give up a lot of homers, I'm tempted to steer you to a homer-suppressing park even though that neutralizes your sluggers.  You might consider a neutral park like Forbes Field or, if you want to capitalize on your high OBP but leave your HR's for the road, try parks like Dodger Stadium, League Park, PNC or Comerica that are conducive to your ability to get on base without bludgeoning your pitching staff with HR's.

5/15/2011 4:31 AM
This post has a rating of , which is below the default threshold.
This post has a rating of , which is below the default threshold.

Well thanks for the kind words, and advice.  One thing I do struggle with is the ballpark, it happens to me every "season." 
This is a interesting league, I have to have  Julian Javier he is what the theme is about or I have chosen him to be part of my theme.  All those pitchers that were noted to be crushed. well they need to be teammates of Julian, so I'm in  a pickle if they get crushed, this theme will have its challenges I see.
I was inking towrd a neutral park, I even considered whatif park.  Thanks for the advice, there is nothing I can do about javier and at least gibson and carlton maybe I can relook at shantz and hall however.  Thanks again.

5/15/2011 10:30 PM
Posted by dahsdebater on 5/14/2011 8:28:00 PM (view original):
The best thing to do is actually look at your opponents' teams and decide where to play him.  The sim treats all hitters as pull hitters, particularly to the outfield.  So if your opponent has more lefties than righties in his lineup, play the guy in left.  If he has more righties, play him in right.

Trying to figure out what your offense is like from numbers without knowing normalization of the players is pretty tough.  196 homeruns in a lineup of all guys from the steroid era is not really going to net you a whole lot in an OL; 196 homers from a lineup of all guys from the '20s will offer a lot more power.  How many CS are there to go along with those steals?  How does  the average normalize?  How much do your guys walk?  Etc.
Wow finally some smart advice on where to play the better of your COFers.  Nicely done.

I do something similar, but look at things from the opposite view.  If my SP are right-handed (or predominantly right-handed if I don't want to micro-manage) I use my rangier OF in right to combat lefty batters.  If I have a bunch of LHSPs, I put the better COF in left. 
5/16/2011 4:11 AM

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.