I have had some mildly curious ones, like 2010 Miguel Cabrera (C/C+) 7 + and 5 - and 1981 Lou Whitaker (B/A) 6+ and 5 -.
But the one that still baffles me to this day is the only time I used 1980 Willie Wilson (B+/A+), about a year and a half ago in center field: 14 + and 5 -.
But more than 5 on both sides? Yeah, I can't say that I remember seeing any.