Which PG would you prefer in D3 for the press defense?

Recruit 1: WE 32

Athleticism	46	High		Perimeter	54	High
Speed	56	Low		Ball Handling	61	High
Rebounding	3	Low		Passing	24	High
Defense	39	High		Stamina	76	Average
Shot Blocking	8	Low		Durability	14	Average
Low-post	24	Low		FT Shooting		High

Recruit 2: WE 33

Athleticism	26	Average		Perimeter	21	High
Speed	66	High		Ball Handling	57	High
Rebounding	13	Average		Passing	47	High
Defense	24	Average		Stamina	70	High
Shot Blocking	1	Low		Durability	42	Low
Low-post	30	High		FT Shooting		Average

Thanks in advance

I would personally go with no.1, because I am a 3-pt shooting whore, but no.2 may be better for the press. He will be an ideal PG, because of BH and PA. And with his speed, he will be a good DIII defender.  

That said, no.1 would be a very good SG in my opinion. 

#2 will be a scoring machine

I had a third player in mind to play SG, I like his combo of ATH/SPD, but do you guys think he'd be a better SG than recruit 1 above?

Recruit 3: WE 48

Athleticism	31	High		Perimeter	25	High
Speed	62	High		Ball Handling	56	Low
Rebounding	12	Average		Passing	35	High
Defense	28	High		Stamina	67	High
Shot Blocking	10	Low		Durability	34	Low
Low-post	12	Average		FT Shooting		High

Thanks for your opinions guys, I'm just trying to decide between these guys

I think you've got to go for #2, if you're looking for a PG.  The defense number won't be great, but the speed and stamina will be huge assets.  I agree with car_crazy: #1 would be a very nice SG, but I think may get eaten alive when facing fast PGs.

I posted before I saw recruit #3.  It may be the decision is really influenced by WE and to a lesser extent by HSGPA.  I usually play M2M and favor defense always, but in the press those high speed & high stamina's can just give opposing teams fits.

I'd take #3. I'm worried about the speed of #1, and the defense of #2 for press. #3's eventual combo of ATH / SPD / DEF / STA will make him an absolute stud defensively. And once his PAS improves into the 50's (and possibly a lot higher), he should get more than his share of both assists and trips to the FT line (where he also has high potential).

#2 is the only legitimate PG in the group.  #3 is the best all-around player.  Sounds like you can take both of them, so that's good.  I don't really like to take a guy who will have #2's defensive struggles, but if you need a PG he's your guy.  At least out of these 3.  It can be hard to find D3 PGs anymore who have a legitimate BH/Pass combo with adequate ATH and DEF to be good on that end of the court.

#2 won't be nearly as bad defensively in the press as he would be in other defenses.  with his speed he can still generate a lot of steals that could turn into easy buckets.  that said 2 and 3 are light years ahead of #1 in my book. i'd like to have both, but if i could only get one and i needed a pg to start right away or as early as next season i'd def take #2.  if i could wait a year to get a starting pg then i'd probably take #3