Ok dahs, so you've made the NT 25 times in 62 seasons with a 27-25 record.

I've made the NT 17 times in 42 seasons with a 9-17 record.

We make the tourney at basically the same clip (a slight edge to me) and you have a better record...if you're saying you're better than me, I still really feel like it's a tough argument to make...I'll give you a slim edge, but I don't suck by any means.

6 is fine.  One thing I think they should add to this game is ability to recruit underclassmen in HS. This would make scholarship management more of a challenge, and scouting would be even more important.  There would be separate position rankings for each year, so the top schools could go after the highly rated underclassmen like they do now with the seniors.  The idea would be that underclassmen would have much lower ratings and high potential would have more uncertainty associated with it.  Large changes throughout HS would be possible, so that a recruit could be off the radar as a soph or jr, but come "out of nowhere" and be very highly rated as a senior.  This might allow coaches at low prestige schools to gamble by signing guys early and hoping they become competitive at a higher level than expected.

this is sadly not a top 5 dumbest of your suggestions, but still, its a terrible one (for the reasons already listed)

hope its going well!

Posted by colonels19 on 4/27/2012 10:02:00 PM (view original):

Ok dahs, so you've made the NT 25 times in 62 seasons with a 27-25 record.

I've made the NT 17 times in 42 seasons with a 9-17 record.

We make the tourney at basically the same clip (a slight edge to me) and you have a better record...if you're saying you're better than me, I still really feel like it's a tough argument to make...I'll give you a slim edge, but I don't suck by any means.

There's more than a slight difference in winning a little over half your games in the postseason versus winning a third of your games in the postseason. It isn't a tough argument to make.

I'm a better fake coach in a fantasy sports world then you are.

Posted by coach_billyg on 4/28/2012 12:53:00 AM (view original):
this is sadly not a top 5 dumbest of your suggestions, but still, its a terrible one (for the reasons already listed)

hope its going well!

What are the top 5?

Posted by bermanap on 4/28/2012 11:27:00 AM (view original):
I'm a better fake coach in a fantasy sports world then you are.

+1