I just took over Clark Atlanta (D2) in the Rupp World. I have two junior point guards who both are B+ in my offense/defense sets. I run a Fastbreak/Press and was wondering which would be the better PG to start.

Carswell:
Ath: 57
Spd: 50
Reb: 26
Def: 75
Shot Blk: 15
LP: 19
PE: 32
BH: 90
Pass: 51
WE: 68
Stam: 84
Dur: 56
FT: A-

Lott
Ath: 69
Spd: 48
Reb: 5
Def: 46
Shot Blk: 9
LP: 7
PE: 36
BH: 84
Pass: 87
WE: 60
Stam: 97
Dura: 28
FT: D+

I'm leaning towards Lott, but Carswell had been simmys choice for last season so I was wondering if my logic for thinking Lott is better is foolish. Yes, Carswell is a better defender and slightly faster but Lott is a lot more balanced in the BH/Pass area. Safe to say, neither can shoot to save their lives!

I would start Lott.

I would start both, no question. They're your two best guards.

The only additional thing Garvin offers is some pe (and even that isn't great). You can still get plenty of minutes and the perimeter shooting that comes with it playing him as the backup at both pg and sg. Meanwhile, his ath is not even DIII-caliber.

I would also start both centers.

I agree completely with Dalter. Start both PG's and both C's and Brandon at SF