my advice is walk away from all of them considering a sim D1.
I don't recall ever seeing a D1 sim drop a recruit and have him open to D2 teams. You could try to wrestle one away but be prepared to spend $20k+.
As you probably know, sims recruit all the players within a block of 40-50 recruits. ie.. the 120th-170th PG. I think them targeting the guys you were looking at means, at least for this season, you were just looking a bit over the D2 ceiling.