Per thejuice6's request, here's an update:
Teams Drafting (in order):
(1) OUTBACKER (Wolverines: Lady Baldwin, Charlie Getzien, Dan Brouthers, Sam Thompson, Hardy Richardson)
(2) SOPHIEGIANTS (White Stockings: Cap Anson, John Clarkson, King Kelly, George Gore, Jocko Flynn)
(3) YAZ_BENDERS (Browns: Tip O'Neill, Bob Caruthers, Dave Foutz, Curt Welch, Arlie Latham)
(4) HACKER7 (Giants: Roger Connor, John Ward, Buck Ewing, Mickey Welch, Tim Keefe)
Draft Picks:
First Round:
(1) Pete Browning - Colonels
(2) Denny Lyons - Athletics
(3) Dan Brouthers - Bisons
(4) Oyster Burns - Orioles
Second Round:
(1) Charlie Ferguson - Quakers
(2) Sam Wise - Beaneaters
(3) Toad Ramsey - Colonels
(4) Henry Boyle - Maroons
Third Round:
(1) Jack Glasscock - Maroons
(2) King Kelly - Beaneaters
(3) John Shaffer - Metropolitans
(4) Henry Larkin - Athletics
Fourth Round:
(1) Jerry Denny - Hoosiers
(2) Harry Stovey - Athletics
(3) Jimmy Say - Blues
(4) Charley Jones - Red Stockings
Fifth Round:
(1) Jim Handiboe - Alleghenys
(2) Yank Robinson - Browns
(3) Hank O'Day - Nationals
(4) George Shoch - Nats