This post could not be converted. To view the original post's thread, click here.

sorry for the formatting, its not going to get any better. Would you veto this deal?

the 2nd team also sent the first team $1 million.

If you were involved in the deal or the controversy, please dont reply. I want unbiased opinions.

Well, I can't see the ratings on the final player, and I'd already say the team getting the second group of players is winning.

The first group of players contains a mediocre long reliever, a mediocre short reliever and a mediocre bench player. The second group contains a better short reliever, a good starting pitcher and whatever the third guy is.

If that third guy is any good, AND the team getting the inferior players is the one forking out the cash, I'd be inclined to suspect n00b rape. Frankly, the starting pitcher alone is worth more than the three shlubs in the first group.

This post could not be converted. To view the original post's thread, click here.

The first group is garbage. I don't see anyone who'd be more than a 25th man. As to whether I'd veto, it depends on the guidelines within the world. But it's lopsided. Very lopsided.

I'd veto.

new forums are awesome.

To be fair I didnt post the salaries, and ages. The players in group A are older (but not too old) and have much larger salaries. Thats why id assume the million was included for budgetary reasons.

New guy got screwed, veto.

How much larger are the salaries? If it's a significant multi-year salary dump, it's possible that it's not unbalanced. Are any of the last three players (especially 1 and 3) significantly overpaid?

Player 1 - 22 years old $327k - 1 season
Player 2 - 25 years old $327k - 1 season
Player 3 - 31 years old $ 2mil - 1 season

for

Player 4 - 31 years od $5 mil X 2 seasons
Player 5 - 32 years old $ 6 mil X 3 seasons
Player 6 - 26 years old $327k X 1 season

salaries are crucial, the first group appears to be young...it may be a salary dump...

it looks very lopsided but if 1 or 2 guys in the 2nd group have burdensome contracts it becomes much more understandable

There's no need for a salary dump in the first season of a world. Really, there's no reason for a salary dump unless you've taken over a massive turd team. But that's just me.