Sports--that's the problem. Compared to the other team, your team has less speed, ath, and reb. You do have more stamina which has been my issue. It's become marathon dynasty.
The press hinges as much or more on stamina than on skillz. Fix the press at the source, don't tweak fatigue in order to fabricate results without fixing the problem.
IRL, virtually any college player can play the same amount. Two teams that rotate 10 will see no difference in fatigue. Fatigue will be equal for two teams that rotate 12. It's the number in the rotation that matters more than some fictitious stamina number pinned to their chest. Is HD really saying that no matter how hard some players train, they'll never be able to finish a marathon? Now that's absurd.