Maybe i Just never noticed because in old engine it was so hard to keep a player from playing all season, but have you always not been able to rescind a redshirt after season had ended.  I thought you could pull them on and off until the next season loads, but that does not look like the case.
I just took over a team which had a player that had not played and so thought I would throw out a redshirt to save me another year, but He did not like it and can not take it back.   I thought you could always undo it if they complained, but like I said never did it after season ended, but I figured until it cycles over to next years stats that should not matter.

are you talking about Ober on your Louisville team? I don't see any reduction in WE.

I just started a thread on this exact same thing. Completely sucks, jnick. I hope that other people see our messages so they do not have to go through this crap.

Ober actually took the redshirt without complaining, I just freaked when I did not see the option of removing  but has this always been the case and we are just now noticing because  more players are making it through the season without playing or is it new?

Just noticing, because it was almost impossible to have a player not play all year before.