I am fine with, even support, having durability matter more, but can we just get rid of the injuries that knock a key player all the way down to under forty percent and put him out for five games?

I don't necessarily agree with you on that point, but an interesting way of adressing this issue (and something I would like to see happen) would be to increase the number of games and/or percentage of the season needed to be missed by a player in order to qualify for a medical redshirt. Coaches dealing with long term injuries to important players might not feel as though they are getting screwed so badly. Just a thought.  

Well, if it were a 15 Durability player, I might feel more charitable, but for a 56 durability, its not exactly a pitiful score.